Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the rare book that deserves its awards and actually gets kids to read. The novel-in-verse format isn't a gimmick—it's the whole point, making the story feel like a mixtape of Josh's life. The basketball is authentic without being exclusionary, and the family dynamics feel real in the best way: loving but messy, supportive but flawed.
The emotional punch comes from the father's health crisis, which forces both boys to reckon with what really matters. It's heavy but not traumatic, and handled with care. Parents should know it's coming, but it's exactly the kind of meaningful conflict that makes kids think about mortality and family without being scared.
If your kid thinks poetry is boring or reading is a chore, hand them this. It moves fast, hits hard, and might actually change their mind about what books can do.
Age Fit
Perfect for middle schoolers ages 10-14, especially those who claim they 'don't like reading.' The verse format and sports angle make it accessible for reluctant readers, while the emotional depth and literary craft satisfy strong readers too. Upper elementary kids can handle it, high schoolers might find it too young unless they're reading it for class.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
92
Models a loving, intact family with involved parents who provide guidance. Brotherhood and family relationships are central, with positive conflict resolution. Mild trash-talking during sports stays age-appropriate. Shows healthy navigation of middle-school crushes and growing pains without being preachy.
Imaginative
88
Written entirely in verse with rhythm and wordplay that makes the form itself part of the storytelling. Josh's 'mad beats' weave basketball, family history, and emotion into creative narrative structure. The novel-in-verse format invites kids to see poetry as accessible and cool, potentially inspiring their own creative writing experiments.
Safe
95
Content is exceptionally clean for middle grade—mild name-calling limited to sports trash-talk, sexual content only extends to crushes and one kiss. The 'heart-stopping climax' involves a parent's serious health crisis (father's heart attack), which is emotionally intense but handled appropriately and serves the story's themes about family and priorities.
Enriching
90
Newbery Medal and Coretta Scott King Award winner that tackles brotherhood, family dynamics, growing up, and consequences of choices. Basketball serves as metaphor for life lessons. Explores grief, responsibility, and communication within a Black family context. The verse format builds literary appreciation while remaining highly readable and engaging for reluctant readers.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
The verse format is a game-changer for reluctant readers—short, punchy lines with rhythm make pages fly by
Shows a loving, involved Black family with two parents who actually parent (refreshing!)
Basketball metaphors work even if your kid has never touched a ball—it's really about growing up and sibling rivalry
Tackles serious themes (health crisis, family conflict, first love) without being heavy-handed or preachy
Won basically every award possible for a reason—it's legitimately good literature that kids actually want to read
⚠
What to Watch For
The father's heart attack is the emotional climax—it's handled well but will hit hard for kids who've dealt with family health scares
Some sports trash-talk and mild name-calling between brothers (nothing shocking, just realistic sibling stuff)
The verse format is either going to click immediately or feel weird—give it 20 pages before deciding
Conversation Starters
"Josh and Jordan have totally different personalities—do you think twins are really that different, or is it exaggerated?"
"Their dad keeps ignoring his health problems even though everyone's worried. Why do you think adults do that?"
"Josh gets really jealous when Jordan starts dating. Have you ever felt left out when a friend got interested in someone new?"
"The book is written like rap lyrics. Do you think that makes it easier or harder to read?"
"What would you do if someone you loved was making choices that could hurt them?"
