Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is the book to hand a kid who's fighting with their sibling and insisting they hate each other. Telgemeier nails the messy reality of family life—the disappointment when your baby sister turns out to be cranky and boring, the years of not quite clicking, the slow realization that you're stuck with each other so you might as well figure it out.

The genius is in the dual timeline: a family road trip (with all its cramped-car chaos) intercut with flashbacks showing how they got here. It's funny, it's real, and it doesn't tie everything up with a neat bow. The parents aren't perfect, the sisters don't become best friends overnight, but there's genuine growth.

The graphic novel format is a huge win for visual learners and kids who find walls of text intimidating. Telgemeier's expressive art does half the emotional heavy lifting. This isn't just 'good for a graphic novel'—it's genuinely excellent storytelling that happens to be in comics form.

If your kid has siblings (especially if they're currently in the 'I hate you' phase), this book will feel like someone finally gets it. And if they're an only child, well, maybe they'll feel a little smug about dodging all that drama.

Age Fit

Perfect for 8-13 year olds, especially those navigating sibling dynamics or family changes. The graphic novel format and relatable humor make it accessible for reluctant readers while the emotional depth keeps older tweens engaged.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

88

A graphic novel memoir that authentically captures sibling dynamics—bickering, jealousy, and eventually finding common ground. Models realistic family relationships including parental tension, but handles it age-appropriately. The road trip framework and flashback structure keep pacing engaging without being chaotic. Telgemeier's signature humor balances the heavier moments of family strain.

Imaginative

72

The graphic novel format itself invites visual literacy and shows how personal stories can be told through sequential art. While it's a memoir (grounded in real events) rather than fantasy, it demonstrates creative storytelling through the dual timeline structure and expressive illustrations. More reflective than inventive—kids won't build worlds from this, but they might be inspired to tell their own family stories.

Safe

92

Very safe for the target age group. Web reviews from Common Sense Media, Plugged In, and parent feedback consistently note it's appropriate for ages 8+. The most sensitive content involves parents' relationship strain (implied but not explicit) and typical sibling conflict. No violence, mature themes, or inappropriate content. The emotional realism might be intense for very young readers but is handled with care.

Enriching

85

Offers genuine emotional intelligence around sibling relationships, family dynamics, and managing disappointment when reality doesn't match expectations. Kids consistently describe it as 'relatable'—a sign it's building empathy and self-awareness. The graphic novel format builds visual literacy skills. Amazon rating of 4.7 and widespread kid reviews praising its relatability suggest strong engagement. Provides vocabulary for complicated family feelings.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Finally, a book that doesn't pretend siblings are best friends—this is the real deal of bickering, jealousy, and eventually figuring it out
The graphic novel format makes it accessible and fast-paced; kids who resist chapter books often devour Telgemeier's work
Handles the messy reality of family life (including parents who aren't perfect) with humor and heart
Builds emotional vocabulary around disappointment, expectations vs. reality, and finding connection despite differences
Eisner Award winner from a #1 NYT bestselling author—this is the gold standard of middle-grade graphic novels

⚠

What to Watch For

Parents' relationship tension is present but handled subtly—good opportunity to talk about how families navigate hard times
The sibling conflict is realistic, which means there's plenty of fighting and frustration before the resolution
Kids without siblings might not connect as deeply, though the family road trip chaos is pretty universal

Conversation Starters

"Raina really wanted a sister, but then Amara wasn't what she expected. Have you ever been super excited about something and then felt disappointed?"
"The sisters fight a lot but end up needing each other. What's something hard about having siblings? What's something good about it?"
"Their parents are going through a tough time. How do you think that affects Raina and Amara?"
"If you could take a road trip anywhere with our family, where would you want to go? What do you think would go wrong?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Sisters