TL;DR: The "I’m Not a Baby" Watchlist
If you're in a hurry and just need to put something on that won't result in an eye-roll that breaks the space-time continuum, here are the top picks for the 9-13 crowd:
- The "Epic Adventure" Pick: Percy Jackson and the Olympians — High production value, feels "big," but stays grounded.
- The "Witty & Weird" Pick: Gravity Falls — It’s a cartoon, but it has a massive cult following among teens and adults for a reason.
- The "Stress-Free" Pick: Is It Cake? — High stakes, zero trauma, weirdly addictive.
- The "Modern Classic" Pick: Avatar: The Last Airbender — If they haven't seen it, this is the gold standard for tween storytelling.
- The "Smart Sitcom" Pick: Abbott Elementary — Fast-paced, funny, and "grown-up" without being inappropriate.
Ask our chatbot for a personalized list based on your kid's favorite games
There is a very specific, slightly painful moment in parenting when you realize your kid has officially entered the "That’s for babies" phase. One day they’re obsessed with Bluey (which, let's be honest, we all still love), and the next, they’re looking at you like you’ve insulted their entire lineage because you suggested a Disney Junior show.
This is the Tween Gap. They are biologically wired to seek out "older" content because they’re trying to figure out where they fit in the social hierarchy. In their world, watching "baby" shows is a one-way ticket to being called "Ohio" (which is tween-speak for weird or cringey) or, heaven forbid, being told they have "zero rizz."
The problem is that the jump from "G-rated cartoon" to "Teen Drama" is a massive, shark-infested canyon. Netflix and YouTube are more than happy to push them toward Stranger Things or even Squid Game way before they’re ready for the gore or the psychological heavy lifting.
Our job isn't to keep them in the nursery; it's to find the shows that feel mature, look "cool," and have actual substance, without the "brain rot" of low-effort YouTube content.
Just because it’s animated doesn’t mean it’s for kids. Tweens know this—they see the older kids talking about anime or adult animation. The trick is finding the shows that bridge that gap with sophisticated writing and high-stakes plots.
Don't let the Disney XD logo fool you. This show is a masterpiece of mystery and lore. It’s basically "Twin Peaks" for kids. It respects the audience's intelligence with long-running puzzles and dark (but age-appropriate) humor. Why it works: It’s genuinely funny for parents, too, and the mystery element makes it feel like a "real" show rather than a sitcom.
If your kid is into Minecraft or Dungeons & Dragons, this is the one. It deals with complex themes like war, loss, and moral ambiguity, but stays within the TV-Y7/PG realm. Why it works: The world-building is deep. It feels like an epic saga, not a Saturday morning cartoon.
The sequel to Avatar: The Last Airbender. While Avatar is perfect, Korra is decidedly more "teen." The characters are older, the romance is a bit more central, and the political themes are surprisingly relevant. Why it works: It feels "edgier" than the original, which is exactly what a 12-year-old wants.
Most tweens are desperate to move into live-action. However, we’re currently in a weird era where "teen" shows are often written for 25-year-olds (think Euphoria or Riverdale). We need to find the middle ground.
Disney+ finally got this right. It’s cinematic, the acting is solid, and it captures that "chosen one" energy that tweens crave. Why it works: It’s a "big budget" production. It looks like a movie, which gives it instant street cred.
You don't even have to be a Star Wars superfan. It’s a space western. It’s cool, it’s sleek, and "Baby Yoda" (Grogu) is the only "cute" thing a tween will still admit to liking. Why it works: It’s part of the cultural zeitgeist. If they watch this, they can actually participate in conversations with older kids and adults.
This is a "grown-up" show that is almost entirely safe for tweens. It’s a mockumentary style (like The Office) which feels very sophisticated to a 6th grader. Why it works: The humor is fast and smart. It doesn't pander.
Learn more about the difference between TV-PG and TV-14
We have to talk about YouTube. For many tweens, "TV" is just a place to watch YouTube on a bigger screen. This is where we run into "Skibidi Toilet" (surreal, loud, and ultimately meaningless) and the endless stream of "challenge" videos that are basically digital junk food.
If your kid says they're bored with Netflix, they’re probably craving the dopamine hit of short-form content. You can redirect this by finding high-quality creators who actually do something.
- For the builders: Mark Rober — Former NASA engineer making insane contraptions. This is "cool" science.
- For the gamers: Instead of just watching loud screaming, point them toward Hermitcraft (a Minecraft server focused on building and community) or creators like Stampy (if they're on the younger end of the tween spectrum).
- The "MrBeast" Factor: MrBeast is the king of the tween world. Is it "good"? It's loud, it's expensive, and it's designed to be addictive. It’s not necessarily "bad," but it’s definitely the fast food of media.
Check out our guide on navigating YouTube's algorithm for tweens
When you're picking shows for this age group, the rating (TV-G, TV-PG, TV-14) only tells half the story. Here’s what you actually need to look for:
- Sarcasm and Social Dynamics: Tweens are learning how to be social beings. Shows like iCarly or older sitcoms are heavy on sarcasm. Make sure your kid understands that "mean funny" on TV is just "mean" in real life.
- Consumerism: Many "cool" shows and YouTube channels are essentially 22-minute commercials for merch or a lifestyle.
- Intensity over Content: Sometimes a show is "clean" (no swearing/sex) but incredibly intense or scary (like Stranger Things). Know your kid’s "spook factor" before hitting play.
The best way to figure out if a show is "too much" is to watch the first two episodes with them. I know, I know—you have laundry, emails, and a life. But the tween years are when they start to shut the door. Sitting on the couch to watch The Good Place (a great pick for older tweens, by the way) is a low-pressure way to stay connected.
Pro-tip: If they say a show is "cool," don't try too hard to agree. Just say, "The cinematography looks decent," or "The writing is actually pretty sharp." If you like it too much, you might accidentally make it "uncool." It’s a delicate dance.
Finding "cool" TV for tweens is about respecting their desire for maturity without throwing them into the deep end. They want to feel like they are graduating from childhood, and the media they consume is their primary way of signaling that.
If you can provide options that have high production value, complex characters, and a bit of "edge"—without the R-rated baggage—you’ll win the weekend.
- Take the Survey: Use Screenwise to see what other parents in your kid's grade are actually allowing. You might find that you're the "strict house" or the "chill house" and can adjust accordingly.
- Audit the YouTube: Spend 10 minutes looking at their "Recommended" feed on YouTube. It will tell you everything you need to know about what they think is "cool" right now.
- The "One For You, One For Me" Rule: Let them pick a show, but you get to pick the next one. It’s a great way to introduce them to classics like The Simpsons (early seasons) or The Great British Baking Show.