This is literary YA at its finest—a Printz winner that treats grief with the seriousness and beauty it deserves. LaCour doesn't rush the healing or tie things up neatly, which makes it feel real.

That said, this is not beach reading. It's quiet, sad, and requires emotional maturity. If your teen is in a good headspace and ready for something that will make them feel deeply (and maybe cry), this is powerful. If they're struggling with loss or depression themselves, check in first—it might be too much, or it might be exactly what they need to feel less alone.

The LGBTQ relationship is handled beautifully and matter-of-factly, which is exactly how it should be. Some parents clutched their pearls in reviews, but Common Sense Media confirms it's discreet and age-appropriate for older teens.

Bottom line: This is a book for readers who want to feel something, not escape everything. It's short, it's gorgeous, and it won't be for everyone—but for the right teen at the right time, it's unforgettable.