Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the YA mystery that launched a thousand book club discussions and got a lot of teens reading who weren't otherwise into books. It's well-crafted, genuinely suspenseful, and the characters are more than their stereotypes.
That said, it's not light reading. There's a death at the center, drug dealing, plenty of swearing, and the whole premise is about secrets dark enough to kill over. It's appropriate for the teen audience it's written for, but parents should know what they're handing their middle schooler.
The book does good work exploring how we judge people, how reputation can trap you, and how high school hierarchies are often bullshit. But it's entertainment first, life lessons second. If your teen likes mysteries and can handle mature content, this will keep them up past bedtime. Just don't hand it to your 10-year-old without reading it first.
Age Fit
Best for ages 13-17, though some mature 11-12 year olds could handle it with parent awareness. The murder mystery format and high school setting will appeal to middle and high schoolers, but the content (death, drugs, profanity, sexual references) makes it solidly YA rather than middle grade.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
55
Murder mystery centered on high school stereotypes with themes of deception, drug dealing, and gossip. Characters grow through adversity and the story models friendship under pressure, but the core premise involves death, secrets, and manipulation. Contains swearing and drug references throughout. Not emotionally toxic, but definitely darker YA territory.
Imaginative
72
Clever whodunit structure that invites readers to piece together clues and suspect everyone. The mystery unfolds through shifting perspectives and layered secrets. Doesn't break new ground in the genre but executes the puzzle-box format well with enough twists to keep readers engaged and theorizing.
Safe
62
Contains mature content including a student death (not graphic but central to plot), drug dealing, underage drinking, references to steroids, swearing throughout, and sexual content/references. Common Sense Media user reviews mention 'a bit too much drugs and swearing' but note it's appropriate for 11-14+ depending on maturity. No graphic violence or explicit sex scenes, but definitely not safe for younger kids to stumble upon.
Enriching
68
Explores themes of reputation, judgment, stereotypes, and how people aren't always what they seem. Characters grapple with identity beyond their high school labels and learn about truth, loyalty, and standing up for what's right. The mystery format builds critical thinking and deductive reasoning. However, it's primarily entertainment-focused rather than deeply transformative.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Genuinely engaging mystery that keeps you guessing—the plot twists land and the whodunit structure is well-executed
Explores how high school labels trap people and challenges stereotypes (the jock, the brain, the beauty, the criminal)
Multiple perspectives let readers see how different people experience the same events and hide different truths
Fast-paced and hard to put down—this is the kind of book that gets reluctant readers hooked
Deals with reputation, judgment, and standing up for what's right when it's easier to stay silent
⚠
What to Watch For
Central plot involves a student's death (not graphic but it's a murder mystery, so death is the whole thing)
Regular profanity, drug dealing subplot, references to steroid use, and underage drinking
Sexual content and references (not explicit scenes but definitely present)
Themes of gossip, blackmail, and reputation damage that could hit close to home for some teens
Conversation Starters
"Which character did you think was guilty at first? What made you change your mind?"
"The book is all about how people see you versus who you really are. Do you ever feel like people have you in a box at school?"
"Simon's gossip app destroyed people's reputations. How is that different from (or similar to) what happens on social media now?"
"If you knew a secret about someone, when would you feel like you had to tell versus keeping it private?"
"The characters all felt trapped by their labels. What do you think your 'label' would be, and is that actually who you are?"
