Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
If you have a kid who thinks history is boring or only cares about ESPN, buy this book immediately. Steve Sheinkin is the gold standard for narrative nonfiction—he finds the craziest true stories and tells them with zero fluff.
It’s a heavy lift emotionally because of the boarding school setting, but it’s balanced by the sheer adrenaline of the football games. It’s one of those rare 'must-reads' that actually earns the title. No BS, it’s just a great book.
Age Fit
Perfect for 10-year-olds and up. It’s written for middle schoolers, but the story is so compelling that high schoolers (and honestly, most parents) will get sucked in too.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
92
It’s a masterclass in resilience. Jim Thorpe and his teammates face systemic attempts to break their spirits, yet they find dignity and brotherhood through sport. It models grit without being cheesy.
Imaginative
88
Sheinkin reconstructs the early 1900s so vividly it feels like a movie. It asks readers to imagine a world where football was a brand-new, lethal experiment and how Indigenous players literally invented the modern game.
Safe
85
It’s nonfiction, so the 'violence' is historical reality. It details the abuse at boarding schools—forced assimilation and cultural erasure—which is heavy but handled with total respect for the middle-grade audience.
Enriching
98
This is top-tier educational content. It covers civil rights, American history, and sports evolution simultaneously. You won't find a better way to teach kids about the Carlisle Indian School.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
It reads like an action movie, not a dry history textbook.
Jim Thorpe is basically a real-life superhero, and kids love finding out he actually existed.
It explains how the 'underdog' Carlisle team basically invented the forward pass and modern football strategy.
It doesn't talk down to kids about the darker parts of American history.
⚠
What to Watch For
Descriptions of the 'Kill the Indian, Save the Man' philosophy can be upsetting for sensitive readers.
The football of 1907 was essentially a legal brawl; expect descriptions of bone-crushing hits and serious injuries.
Honest depictions of the racism and cheating the team faced from white officials and opponents.
Conversation Starters
"Why do you think the government tried so hard to make the students forget their own languages?"
"Pop Warner was a genius coach, but did he always have the players' best interests at heart?"
"How did Jim Thorpe handle it when people treated him unfairly because of his heritage?"
"If the Carlisle team 'invented' modern football, why don't we hear about them as much as NFL teams?"