Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is one of those rare picture books that adults remember years later because it doesn't talk down to kids about hard things. Economic inequality, peer pressure, the ache of wanting what you can't have—Boelts gets it all on the page without making it a morality tale.
Jeremy isn't a saint. He buys too-small thrift store shoes because he wants them that badly, wears them until his feet hurt, and only then realizes his friend Antonio's situation is worse. The generosity comes from experience, not a lecture. That's good writing.
The 4.8 Amazon rating and consistent 4-8 age recommendations across multiple sources suggest this lands well. It's been in print since 2009 and still gets assigned in classrooms, which means it hasn't aged poorly. If you're looking for a book that opens conversations about money, empathy, and what actually matters without being insufferable about it, this is the one.
Age Fit
Best for K-3 (ages 5-8), right in the sweet spot where kids are starting to navigate peer pressure and understand economic differences but still concrete enough thinkers to need a story like this. Might feel a bit young for 4th graders unless they're particularly empathetic or experiencing similar circumstances.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
92
A deeply empathetic story about a boy learning to value what he has over what he wants. Jeremy's relationship with his grandma is tender and realistic—she's raising him on limited means but with clear love. The book doesn't shy away from economic hardship (his shoes literally fall apart at school, causing embarrassment) but handles it with dignity. The resolution—Jeremy giving his too-small thrift store shoes to a friend who needs them even more—is earned, not saccharine. Models genuine generosity and perspective-taking without being preachy.
Imaginative
68
This is a realistic fiction picture book grounded in everyday life—no fantasy elements, no world-building. Noah Z. Jones's illustrations are expressive and capture the emotional beats well, but the story itself doesn't invite creative play or exploration beyond the narrative. It's imaginative in its emotional intelligence and in helping kids see their own experiences reflected, but it's not asking them to build or create anything new. Solid storytelling, not particularly inventive in form.
Safe
98
Completely safe for the target age range (K-3). The most 'difficult' content is the social embarrassment Jeremy feels when his shoes fall apart at school and the economic reality that his grandma can't afford the trendy shoes. These are age-appropriate challenges that many kids face. No violence, scary content, or mature themes. The emotional vulnerability might resonate deeply with kids experiencing similar circumstances, but that's therapeutic, not triggering.
Enriching
88
This book does real work. It tackles consumerism, peer pressure, economic inequality, empathy, and generosity in 40 pages without feeling like a lesson. Kids living in poverty see themselves represented with respect. Kids with means get a window into why not everyone can have 'those shoes.' The shift from wanting to giving is emotionally authentic—Jeremy's feet hurt, he realizes his friend Antonio's shoes are even worse, and he makes a choice. It builds emotional literacy and ethical reasoning. The 4.8 Amazon rating and starred reviews suggest it lands well with both kids and adults.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Handles economic inequality with unusual dignity—Jeremy's grandma says they don't have room for 'want,' just 'need,' and it doesn't feel like a lecture
The peer pressure is real: everyone at school has those shoes, and Jeremy's fall apart in front of classmates—kids who've felt this will feel this
Jeremy's choice to give away the too-small shoes he desperately wanted is earned through the story, not imposed by an adult telling him what to do
Starred review from Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books calls it 'witty' and 'wise'—rare combo for a book about values
Noah Z. Jones's illustrations capture the emotional beats without overdoing it
⚠
What to Watch For
Kids from families with economic stress might see themselves here—that's the point, but be ready to talk about it
The social embarrassment scene (shoes falling apart at school) is brief but might sting for sensitive kids who've experienced similar moments
Some kids might need help understanding why Jeremy can't just get the shoes—if your family hasn't talked about money constraints, this is your opening
Conversation Starters
"Have you ever really, really wanted something that other kids had? What was it like when you didn't get it?"
"Why do you think Jeremy decided to give the shoes to Antonio even though he wanted them so badly?"
"Jeremy's grandma says they have room for 'need' but not 'want.' What do you think is the difference?"
"How do you think Jeremy felt when his shoes fell apart at school? Have you ever felt embarrassed like that?"
"At the end, Jeremy gets warm boots from his grandma. Do you think he still wants 'those shoes'?"