Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is exactly what it says on the tin: a wholesome, easy-reading sports series that won't give you a single moment of parental concern. Alex Morgan knows soccer, and the authentic details show—but the plot is paint-by-numbers.
It's the literary equivalent of a Disney Channel show: pleasant, positive, predictable. Your soccer-loving kid will breeze through it and probably ask for the sequels. Your bookworm who wants complex characters and unexpected twists? They'll be bored by page 50.
The real win here is safety and wholesomeness without being preachy. In a middle grade landscape where even 'kids' books can surprise you with heavy content, The Kicks is reliably G-rated. It's not going to change anyone's life, but it's solid entertainment that models good values. Sometimes that's exactly what you need.
Age Fit
Perfect for ages 8-12, especially girls who play sports or are navigating middle school friendships. The reading level is accessible for third graders, but the middle school setting resonates most with 10-12 year olds.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
92
Models confidence, determination, resilience, and teamwork through a positive protagonist. Strong family and team dynamics with realistic friendship building. Parent reviews consistently praise its wholesome nature and G-rated content. No mean-spirited behavior or toxic dynamics.
Imaginative
58
Straightforward sports story with predictable underdog-team-makes-good arc. While it encourages problem-solving and teamwork, it doesn't push creative boundaries or invite much imaginative play beyond standard sports narrative. Competently told but formulaic.
Safe
98
Extremely safe with no content concerns. Multiple sources confirm it's 'very G-rated' with no violence, mature themes, or inappropriate content. No surprise elements that would catch parents off-guard. Perfect for independent reading without worry.
Enriching
72
Teaches valuable lessons about perseverance, friendship, adapting to change, and working together toward a goal. Positive female role model in sports. However, it's light entertainment rather than deeply thought-provoking—kids will enjoy it and learn some social-emotional skills, but it won't fundamentally expand their worldview.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Written by an actual Olympic gold medalist—kids get authentic soccer details and a real role model
Refreshingly G-rated with zero content concerns in an age where that's genuinely hard to find
Strong friendship dynamics and realistic middle school social navigation without the drama
Teaches resilience and adaptability through Devin's cross-country move and new-school challenges
Easy, fast read that reluctant readers can fly through while still getting positive messages
⚠
What to Watch For
Pretty formulaic underdog sports story—if your kid has read one 'save the team' book, they've kind of read them all
Best suited for kids who already like soccer; non-athletes may find it less engaging
Light on literary complexity—this is popcorn reading, not award-winning prose
Conversation Starters
"Devin had to start over at a new school. What would be hardest for you about moving somewhere new?"
"The Kicks' coach didn't care if they won or lost. How would that feel different from having a coach who really cares?"
"Devin made friends with girls who were all really different. What do you think makes a good team?"