Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is exactly what you want in an early reader: accessible, genuinely funny, emotionally healthy, and completely safe. Ben Clanton nails the Frog and Toad vibe for a new generation—two friends with different personalities who balance each other out and navigate small adventures with heart.
The graphic novel format is clutch for kids who are intimidated by text-heavy books, and the underwater setting with a narwhal who thinks he's a unicorn is just quirky enough to feel fresh. The stories are simple but not simplistic—there's real emotional intelligence in how Narwhal helps Jelly when he's feeling blue.
This won't blow your mind as an adult, but it's not trying to. It's trying to make a 6-year-old feel like a champion reader while sneaking in lessons about friendship and believing in yourself. Mission accomplished. The 4.9 Amazon rating isn't lying—this series is beloved for good reason.
Age Fit
Perfect for ages 5-8, especially kids transitioning to chapter books or who need confidence-building with reading. The graphic novel format and simple vocabulary work well for early elementary, though the humor and friendship themes can appeal up to age 9 or 10 for younger-skewing readers.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
95
Models friendship, kindness, and believing in yourself and others. Narwhal's happy-go-lucky nature paired with Jelly's grounded personality creates a balanced emotional dynamic. The stories focus on helping friends, lifting each other up when feeling down, and finding inner strengths—all without being preachy or saccharine.
Imaginative
88
The superhero premise with underwater characters is playful and whimsical. Narwhal's quest to discover their superpower invites kids to think creatively about what makes someone special. The graphic novel format with Clanton's charming illustrations sparks visual engagement. Bonus fun facts about marine life add educational curiosity.
Safe
98
This is a gentle, conflict-free early reader graphic novel. No scary content, no mature themes, no surprise emotional gut-punches. The conflicts are soft (Jelly feeling blue, helping a friend find their way home) and resolved with friendship. Perfect for independent reading without parental pre-screening needed.
Enriching
82
Strong emotional literacy around friendship, empathy, and self-confidence. The graphic novel format builds reading skills for emerging readers transitioning from picture books. Marine life facts add educational value. However, the stories are simple and straightforward—this is more about gentle character lessons than deep cognitive challenge.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Gateway drug for reluctant readers—graphic novel format with simple text and adorable illustrations makes reading feel effortless
Models healthy friendship without being preachy: Narwhal's optimism balances Jelly's realism, and they genuinely support each other
Zero scary content or emotional landmines—you can hand this to a kindergartener without pre-reading
Bonus marine life facts sneak in learning while kids are having fun
Short enough (64 pages) that early readers feel accomplished finishing a 'real book'
⚠
What to Watch For
This is gentle and sweet—if your kid craves action-packed stories, they might find it too mellow
The humor is silly and punny (waffle obsession, anyone?), which some kids will love and others will find corny
Part of a 10-book series, so be prepared for requests for the whole collection
Conversation Starters
"If you could have any superpower, what would it be? What do you think Narwhal and Jelly's superpowers are?"
"Have you ever helped a friend when they were feeling sad like Narwhal did for Jelly?"
"What's something that makes you special or different, like how Narwhal loves waffles?"
"Which character are you more like—happy-go-lucky Narwhal or more careful Jelly?"
