Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is one of those rare picture books that genuinely works for everyone. It's simple enough that a 4-year-old can follow along (a crayon draws the wrong color! a friend helps him!), but sophisticated enough that it's become a staple in elementary classrooms discussing identity, diversity, and acceptance.

The genius is in how non-didactic it is. Michael Hall never says 'be yourself!' or 'labels are bad!' He just shows a crayon struggling, trying, failing, and finally finding relief when someone sees him for who he really is. The emotional arc is real without being manipulative.

Parents love it because it opens conversations about authenticity without forcing them. Teachers love it because it works as a springboard for discussing everything from peer pressure to gender identity to neurodiversity. Kids love it because the illustrations are engaging and the story has a satisfying resolution.

Is it going to blow your mind with literary innovation? No. But it does exactly what a great picture book should do: tells a simple story that reveals something true about being human.

Age Fit

Perfect for ages 4-10, with preschoolers enjoying the colorful story and older elementary kids grasping the deeper themes about identity and acceptance. The simple format keeps it accessible for early readers while the metaphor gives it staying power.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

95

Models empathy, acceptance, and the courage to be yourself despite external pressure. The other crayons and characters are well-meaning (not malicious), creating a supportive emotional environment even when Red is struggling. The resolution celebrates authenticity without shaming those who mislabeled him.

Imaginative

88

Clever visual metaphor using crayons and labels to explore identity. The illustrations are colorful and engaging, using the medium itself (art supplies) as characters. Invites kids to think abstractly about the difference between labels and reality, and sparks creative discussions about self-expression.

Safe

98

Zero content concerns—no violence, scary elements, or inappropriate material. The emotional struggle is age-appropriate and resolved positively. Common Sense Media notes it's 'infused with emotional smarts and empathy' with no red flags for young readers.

Enriching

92

Tackles identity, self-acceptance, and authenticity in an accessible way that works on multiple levels. Builds empathy for those who feel different or misunderstood. Opens conversations about labels, expectations, and being true to yourself. The metaphor is simple enough for preschoolers but sophisticated enough to resonate with older kids (and adults) dealing with identity questions.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

The metaphor works brilliantly on multiple levels—little kids see a crayon solving a problem, older kids (and adults) see a story about identity, authenticity, and societal pressure
Emotionally intelligent without being preachy: Red's struggle feels real, and the well-meaning attempts to 'fix' him ring true for anyone who's felt misunderstood
Opens natural conversations about being yourself, labels (literal and figurative), and accepting others as they are
The illustrations are colorful, clean, and clever—using actual crayon drawings to tell the story
Has become a go-to book for teachers and parents discussing diversity, gender identity, neurodiversity, and acceptance without being heavy-handed

⚠

What to Watch For

Some kids might need help understanding the metaphor—younger readers may take it literally (just a crayon story) while missing the deeper meaning, which is totally fine
The theme of struggling to meet others' expectations could resonate deeply with sensitive kids who feel 'different'—might prompt big feelings or questions
Many adults read this as a transgender allegory (which the author has neither confirmed nor denied), so be prepared for questions if your kid picks up on that subtext

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think Red kept drawing blue things even when everyone told him to draw red things?"
"Have you ever felt like people expected you to be a certain way, but it didn't feel right to you?"
"What do you think about the other crayons trying to help Red? Were they being mean or nice?"
"What would you have done if you were Red's friend?"
"Do you think labels (like the one on Red) can sometimes be wrong about people?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Related Guides

Books About Gender Expression and Identity: A Parent's Guide

Age-appropriate reads that help kids explore identity, empathy, and understanding diverse experiences.

Beyond Pink and Blue: A Parent’s Guide to Books About Gender Identity

Help your little ones explore identity and empathy through inclusive stories that make big concepts easy to talk about.

Red: A Crayon's Story - When Your Preschooler's Favorite Book Tackles Identity

How this picture book about a blue crayon labeled red opens conversations about self-discovery and acceptance.

Writing about Red: A Crayon's Story? Put this WISE score on your site