This is the real deal—literary middle grade fantasy from a Newbery Medalist that doesn't talk down to kids. The Filipino folklore foundation makes it stand out in a sea of European-inspired fantasy, and the gender role subversion feels earned, not preachy.

The 'beautiful horror vibe' is accurate. It's not scary-scary, but there's genuine danger, eerie creatures, and the weight of knowing many have died trying what Lalani attempts. Sensitive kids might struggle, but for readers ready for stakes and tension, it's compelling.

Some reviews note the ending doesn't quite deliver on the buildup, which is fair—this is more about the journey and character growth than epic battles. It's contemplative fantasy, beautifully written, with real emotional depth. Not every kid will have patience for the pacing, but the right reader will be transported.