Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Here's the deal: Icebreaker went viral on BookTok, has a cute cover with ice skates, and sounds like a fun enemies-to-lovers college sports romance. And for adult romance readers, it delivers exactly that—plus extremely graphic sex scenes that dominate the book.

The problem? It's being passed around high schools like it's a YA novel, and parents are horrified when they actually flip through it. Reddit is full of posts from parents saying 'I thought this was a silly teen romance—it's absolutely hardcore porn.' Common Sense Media, Bark, and every parent forum agree: this is 18+ only, and even then only for readers who knowingly want explicit erotica.

If you're an adult who loves spicy romance novels, go for it. But if your teen is asking for this because their friends have it or BookTok made it look cute, pump the brakes and have a real conversation about content. The marketing is misleading, and this is not the hill to die on for 'letting teens read what they want.' There are plenty of actual YA sports romances that won't make you both uncomfortable.

Age Fit

This is an adult romance novel (18+) with extremely explicit sexual content. Despite the college setting and viral TikTok popularity among younger readers, parent safety organizations and reviewers unanimously agree this is not appropriate for teens. Even mature 17-18 year olds should only read if comfortable with graphic erotica.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

35

This is a New Adult romance with extremely graphic, explicit sexual content that multiple parent reviewers describe as 'hardcore pornography.' While the central relationship involves consent and the emotional arc shows vulnerability and connection, the detailed sexual descriptions dominate the narrative in ways that aren't emotionally healthy for teen readers. The book models some positive relationship dynamics but is packaged primarily as erotica with a sports romance wrapper.

Imaginative

42

The figure skating/hockey rivalry setup has some creative potential, and the forced-proximity trope on shared ice creates interesting spatial dynamics. However, this is a fairly paint-by-numbers TikTok romance following well-worn New Adult formulas. The 'enemies to lovers' arc is predictable, and the college sports setting, while specific, doesn't break new ground. It's competently executed genre fiction but brings little originality to the table.

Safe

20

Multiple parent safety organizations (Common Sense Media, Bark) and parent forums unanimously flag this book as containing extremely graphic, detailed sexual content that would be inappropriate and shocking for teens to encounter. Reddit parents describe scenes as 'absolutely hardcore porn,' and Bark recommends ages 17-18+ only for mature readers. This isn't a book with a few fade-to-black moments—it's explicit erotica marketed with a YA-adjacent cover and premise that has caught many parents off guard.

Enriching

38

As escapist romance, it delivers what it promises: a feel-good story about ambition, partnership, and vulnerability. Readers see characters juggling athletic goals with personal relationships, and there's some exploration of trust and communication. However, the educational value is minimal—this is cotton candy entertainment. The 4.3 Amazon rating suggests readers enjoy it, but it's not building critical thinking skills or offering meaningful life lessons beyond 'communicate with your partner.'

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

For adults who love romance novels, it's a fun, low-stakes sports romance with chemistry and banter
The figure skating/hockey world provides a specific, athletic backdrop that fans of sports romance appreciate
Explores themes of ambition, partnership, and vulnerability between two driven college athletes
Massive TikTok following means it's culturally relevant and widely discussed among adult romance readers

⚠

What to Watch For

This is NOT a teen book despite the college setting and cute cover—it contains extremely graphic, detailed sexual content that parent reviewers consistently describe as pornographic
The marketing and TikTok virality make it look like a sweet YA sports romance, which has caught countless parents off guard when their teens bring it home
Common Sense Media, Bark, and parent forums all recommend 18+ only, and even then only for readers comfortable with explicit erotica
If your teen is asking for this because of BookTok, have a frank conversation about content expectations and what 'spicy' actually means in romance novel terms

Conversation Starters

"What are your friends saying about this book? Do they know how explicit the content actually is?"
"Let's talk about the difference between romance novels marketed to adults versus books written for teens—and why that matters"
"If you're interested in sports romance, let me help you find books that have the same fun dynamics without the graphic sexual content"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic