Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the real deal—Acevedo doesn't sugarcoat grief or family dysfunction, but she also doesn't wallow in misery. The verse format is a gift for teens who find traditional novels intimidating, and the dual perspective structure keeps pages turning even when the content is heavy.
The 14+ rating is spot-on. Younger middle schoolers might technically be able to read it, but the emotional complexity—loving a parent who betrayed your family, processing sudden death, dealing with sexual harassment—deserves a reader who can sit with discomfort. This isn't trauma porn; it's an honest look at how families fracture and sometimes, painfully, heal.
The Dominican-American experience is rendered with specificity and love, and the sisterhood that develops feels earned, not Disney-fied. If your teen is ready for literature that treats them like the almost-adults they are, this delivers.
Age Fit
Best for ages 14+ who can handle emotionally mature themes. The verse format makes it accessible for reluctant readers, but the content—parental death, sexual harassment, family betrayal—requires emotional maturity. Strong choice for high schoolers navigating complex feelings about family.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
72
Acevedo handles grief, family secrets, and complex emotions with genuine care. The novel explores a father's double life and his daughters' journey through loss without sensationalizing. Models forgiveness and sisterhood in the face of devastating betrayal. Points deducted for sexual harassment/stalking content and the emotional weight of parental death, which requires maturity to process.
Imaginative
81
Novel-in-verse format is creative and accessible, alternating between two sisters' perspectives across countries. The dual narrative structure invites readers to piece together the family's story. Acevedo's verse style is distinctive and musical, making heavy themes more digestible. Strong sense of place in both NYC and Dominican Republic.
Safe
58
Common Sense Media rates this 14+ for good reason. Contains delicate but explicit handling of parental death in a plane crash, stalking, sexual harassment, and medical/birthing scenes. Not graphic or gratuitous, but these are serious trigger topics that could be genuinely upsetting for younger or unprepared readers. The sexual harassment and stalking elements are particularly concerning for sensitive readers.
Enriching
88
Powerful exploration of grief, identity, family secrets, and cultural duality. Readers gain insight into Dominican-American experience, complex family dynamics, and the messy reality of loving flawed people. The sisterhood that emerges from tragedy offers meaningful lessons about forgiveness and found family. Award-winning author with strong literary craft.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Elizabeth Acevedo's verse format makes emotionally complex material more digestible and beautiful—it reads fast but hits deep
Honest portrayal of loving someone who was deeply flawed; teaches that people can be both good and hurtful at once
Strong Dominican-American representation with authentic cultural details and bilingual elements
The sisterhood that emerges from betrayal is genuinely moving—shows reconciliation without sugarcoating pain
Perfect for teens processing complex family dynamics or grief; validates that messy feelings are normal
⚠
What to Watch For
Parental death is the central event—this will be tough for kids who've experienced loss or have anxiety about losing parents
Sexual harassment and stalking subplot involving one sister; handled seriously but could be triggering
The father's double life and infidelity is the core conflict—may prompt questions about marriage and trust
Medical and birthing scenes are present but not graphic; still, heads up for squeamish readers
Conversation Starters
"Both girls had very different relationships with their dad. How can the same person be so different to different people?"
"Camino and Yahaira are angry at their father but also grieving him. Can you feel both things at once about someone?"
"The sisters had to decide whether to forgive their dad and each other. What does forgiveness actually mean—does it erase what happened?"
"How did their different lives in NYC and the Dominican Republic shape who they became?"
"What would you do if you suddenly discovered you had a sibling you never knew about?"