But Why – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

But Why

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

podcast

93%

WISE Score

Kids ask the questions, adults find the answers—a genuinely curious podcast that treats children's wonder like the valuable thing it is.

But Why

podcast

Clean

93%

WISE Score

Kids ask the questions, adults find the answers—a genuinely curious podcast that treats children's wonder like the valuable thing it is.

Jump to

Also rated on

Screenwise Verdict

This is what kids' podcasts should be: smart without being condescending, educational without being boring, and genuinely responsive to what children actually want to know.

The format is simple—kids record questions, the hosts bring in experts or do research, and everyone learns something. Topics range from the concrete (how do erasers work?) to the philosophical (why do people die?) and it's all delivered in a warm, accessible way that respects children's intelligence.

It's one of those rare pieces of kids' media that parents can actually enjoy too, and it's perfect for filling car time with something better than the Encanto soundtrack for the 47th time. The production quality is solid, the pacing is calm without being sleepy, and there's a real sense that the creators care about fostering curiosity.

If your kid is in that question-asking phase (which, let's be honest, never really ends for some of them), this is a fantastic resource.

Age Fit

Best for ages 5-12, though the sweet spot is probably 6-10 when kids are naturally full of questions and can follow longer explanations. Younger kids can enjoy it with a parent to help clarify, and older tweens might still find it interesting depending on the topic.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Kid-led format where children ask genuine questions and receive thoughtful, age-appropriate answers. Models curiosity, respect for learning, and healthy inquiry without chaos or negativity. Topics range from nature to science to philosophy, all delivered in a calm, supportive tone.

Imaginative

Encourages kids to ask big questions about the world—'Why is the sky blue?' 'What happens when we die?' 'How do languages work?'—and demonstrates that curiosity itself is valuable. Invites children to think critically and wonder about everything from the mundane to the existential. The format inherently sparks imagination by validating that no question is too big or too weird.

Safe

Extremely safe audio content designed specifically for children. No mature themes, explicit language, or inappropriate content. Produced by Vermont Public Radio with editorial standards. Can be played in the car, at home, or anywhere without concern. Topics are handled with care—even heavy subjects like death or the end of the world are approached in age-appropriate, non-scary ways.

Enriching

Genuinely educational without being preachy. Kids learn about science, nature, language, culture, and philosophy through expert interviews and clear explanations. Builds critical thinking skills and validates intellectual curiosity. The show demonstrates research and inquiry processes, teaching kids how to seek answers. Entertaining enough to hold attention while delivering real knowledge.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Kid-driven content where real children submit actual questions they're wondering about
Tackles everything from 'Why do we have to wear clothes?' to 'What is time?' with equal respect and clarity
Perfect for car rides, chores, or quiet time—no screens required
Models that asking questions is good, curiosity is valued, and learning is a lifelong adventure
Produced by Vermont Public Radio with actual editorial standards and expert guests

⚠

What to Watch For

Some episodes tackle big topics like death or the end of the world—handled gently, but you might want to preview if your kid is particularly anxious
Requires decent attention span; younger kids (under 5) might zone out on longer explanations
Not every episode will grip every kid—some topics are niche or might not land with your particular child's interests

Conversation Starters

"What question would you want to ask if you could submit one to the show?"
"Did that answer surprise you? What did you think the answer would be before?"
"What's something you've always wondered about but never asked?"
"Should we try to find the answer to your question together, like they do on the podcast?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic