Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is a solid, no-frills biography that does exactly what it promises: teaches kids about Babe Ruth's journey from troubled kid to sports legend. The 'Who Was?' series is reliably educational and age-appropriate, and Joan Holub knows how to write for this audience.
The book doesn't shy away from Babe's imperfections—the partying, the lack of discipline—but frames them in a way that's honest without being inappropriate. That's actually refreshing. Kids get a real person, not a sanitized hero.
That said, this isn't going to blow anyone's mind. It's straightforward biographical writing with black-and-white illustrations. If your kid loves baseball or is working through the 'Who Was?' series, they'll enjoy it. If they're lukewarm on sports or prefer more narrative-driven books, this might feel like homework. The 4.8 Amazon rating and positive kid reviews suggest it hits the mark for its target audience, but it's not a must-read unless you're specifically looking for sports biographies.
Age Fit
Best for ages 7-12, especially kids interested in sports, American history, or biographies. Reading level is accessible for independent readers in 2nd-6th grade. Probably too dry for teens unless they're serious baseball history buffs.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
82
Rags-to-riches sports biography that celebrates perseverance and talent. Acknowledges Babe's flaws (out of shape, partying) without glorifying them, and highlights his 'big heart.' The reform school background is handled appropriately for the age group, showing how Ruth found his path through baseball. Emotionally grounded and age-appropriate.
Imaginative
58
Straightforward biographical format from the 'Who Was?' series—solid historical facts but not particularly creative in presentation. Black-and-white illustrations throughout add some visual interest. It's informative rather than imaginative, though it does transport readers to early 1900s baseball culture. Doesn't invite much creative exploration beyond learning about a historical figure.
Safe
95
Biography book with no concerning content. Mentions reform school and Babe's 'handful' behavior as a kid, plus his adult lifestyle ('out on the town'), but all handled in age-appropriate, educational context. No violence, mature themes, or inappropriate content. Books in this series are consistently safe for young readers.
Enriching
75
Solid educational value about American sports history, perseverance, and overcoming difficult circumstances. Kids learn about the 1900s, baseball's golden age, and how talent can change your life trajectory. The acknowledgment of Babe's imperfections alongside his achievements provides nuanced character study. Joan Holub is a prolific, respected children's author. Good entry point for sports-interested kids to engage with history.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Perfect for baseball fans who want to learn about one of the sport's most iconic figures
Rags-to-riches story shows how talent and determination can overcome a rough start in life
Doesn't sugarcoat Babe's flaws—he partied, was often out of shape, but had genuine heart
Part of the reliable 'Who Was?' series with 130+ titles from experienced author Joan Holub
Accessible length and reading level for 7-12 year olds, with illustrations throughout
⚠
What to Watch For
Mentions reform school and troubled childhood—handled age-appropriately but worth a heads up
References to Babe's adult lifestyle (drinking, partying) are present but not detailed
Straightforward biographical format may not hook kids who aren't already into sports or history
Conversation Starters
"Babe Ruth started out in a reform school but became one of the greatest athletes ever. What do you think helped him turn his life around?"
"The book mentions Babe was 'often out of shape' but still amazing at baseball. How do you think natural talent and hard work balance out?"
"If you could ask Babe Ruth one question about his life, what would it be?"
"Why do you think people still talk about Babe Ruth even though he played baseball almost 100 years ago?"
