Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is solid middle-grade realistic fiction that handles adoption, sibling relationships, and childhood worry with warmth and authenticity. It's not flashy or trendy, but it does what it sets out to do well.
The science project angle gives kids a concrete example of creative problem-solving, and the friendship trio feels genuine. The adoption from China is treated matter-of-factly, which is refreshing—it's part of the story without being THE story.
That said, this is gentle, character-driven stuff. Kids who need constant plot momentum or fantastical elements will get bored. But for the right reader—especially one navigating sibling dynamics or family changes—this hits the spot. The 4.5 Amazon rating suggests it resonates with its audience, even if it's not going to light the world on fire.
Age Fit
Best for ages 7-11, particularly kids dealing with new siblings, interested in adoption stories, or who enjoy quieter, realistic friendship and family tales. The baby health concern requires some emotional maturity but is handled gently enough for younger elementary readers.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
A gentle story about family, friendship, and learning to be a good sister. Models empathy, cooperation, and devotion without being saccharine. Anna's worry about her adopted baby sister not thriving is age-appropriate emotional content that shows realistic family challenges without being overwhelming.
Imaginative
72
The science project element adds a problem-solving dimension, and the adoption storyline from China offers cross-cultural exposure. However, this is primarily a realistic contemporary story rather than one that pushes creative boundaries or invites much imaginative play beyond the text itself.
Safe
95
Extremely safe middle-grade content with no concerning elements. The baby's health scare is handled sensitively and age-appropriately. Adoption is presented positively. No violence, mature themes, or content that would surprise or upset young readers.
Enriching
80
Tackles meaningful themes like sibling relationships, adoption, cultural identity, and using science/creativity to solve problems. The story builds empathy and shows how friendship and family support work through challenges. Solid emotional intelligence development for the target age group.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Thoughtful portrayal of adoption from China and sibling bonding that feels genuine rather than preachy
Shows kids problem-solving through science and creativity rather than magic or luck
Friendship dynamics between Anna, Laura, and Camille model healthy peer relationships
Addresses real family concerns (baby not thriving) with age-appropriate seriousness and hope
Good for kids navigating their own sibling relationships or curious about adoption
⚠
What to Watch For
The baby's health struggles might worry sensitive kids—good opportunity to discuss how families handle scary situations
This is a sequel, so kids might want to read The Year of the Book first for full context
Quiet, character-driven story—won't appeal to kids who need constant action or adventure
Conversation Starters
"Anna worries about being a good sister. What do you think makes someone a good sibling?"
"The friends use science to try to help the baby. What would you try if you wanted to solve a problem?"
"How do you think Anna's family prepared for adopting a baby from another country?"
"Have you ever worried about someone you love being sick or struggling? What helped you feel better?"
