Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This isn't a bedtime story you read for a laugh. It’s a heavy, honest, and visually stunning exploration of grief.
It’s famous in the 'bibliotherapy' world for a reason: it doesn't lie to kids. If your family is going through it, or if your kid is asking the big, scary questions about death, this is the gold standard.
Just be prepared to have a few tissues handy for yourself—the writing is sharp and doesn't pull its punches.
Age Fit
Best for ages 5 to 10. It’s a 'read-together' book for sure. Don't just leave this on a shelf; it’s meant to be a bridge for a conversation you probably don't want to have but might need to.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
85
It handles the heaviest possible topic—the death of a parent—with total emotional honesty. It doesn't sugarcoat the boy's anger or his dad's visible grief, which actually makes it more 'wholesome' than a book that pretends everything is fine.
Imaginative
78
The story is told through 'kid logic.' The way the boy tries to trap his mom's scent in the house or uses a physical scar to stay connected to her is a deeply creative, if heartbreaking, look at a child's internal world.
Safe
92
It’s a picture book, so there's no 'content' to worry about in terms of violence or language. The only 'danger' is the emotional weight. It's safe, but it's a 'handle with care' situation because it will spark big feelings.
Enriching
96
This is a masterclass in empathy. It gives kids a vocabulary for grief that isn't just 'I'm sad.' It validates the weird, messy feelings that come with loss, which is incredibly high-level emotional work for a 5-year-old.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
It doesn't talk down to kids or use flowery metaphors; it gets into the gritty reality of being a sad, angry little boy.
The 'kid logic'—like picking a scab to remember a voice—is heartbreakingly relatable for children dealing with big losses.
Olivier Tallec’s illustrations are expressive without being overly busy, letting the emotions breathe on the page.
It’s a perfect tool for parents who are struggling to find the right words for a permanent goodbye.
⚠
What to Watch For
The boy picks at a scab on his knee until it bleeds because he thinks it helps him hear his mom's voice. It’s a metaphor, but sensitive kids might find it a bit literal/gross.
The depiction of the dad is very real—he’s described as looking like a 'crumpled washcloth.' It shows that adults don't always have it together, which might be a new concept for some kids.
Conversation Starters
"Why do you think the boy was so worried about opening the windows?"
"The boy felt really angry at his mom for leaving. Is it okay to be mad even when you're sad?"
"What are some ways we can remember people we love that don't involve hurting our knees like the boy did?"
"How did Grandma help the boy feel a little bit better without pretending the mom wasn't gone?"