Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Look, I get it—the book is everywhere, it won a Christopher Award, and those foil scales are objectively gorgeous. Your toddler will be transfixed.

But let's be honest about what's happening here: Rainbow Fish is beautiful and proud, the other fish ice him out, he gets sad and lonely, and a wise octopus tells him to give away his scales. So he does—literally tears off pieces of himself—and suddenly everyone likes him. The end.

That's... not a great lesson? It's not about discovering generosity or learning empathy. It's about conforming, diminishing yourself, and buying friendship through material gifts. The fact that this is held up as a wholesome sharing story is kind of wild when you think about it for more than five seconds.

That said, it's a 30-year-old picture book, not a manifesto. Read it for the pretty pictures, enjoy the sparkles, and then maybe follow up with 'You know, real friends like you for YOU, not for what you give them.' It's a decent conversation starter if you're willing to do the work. Just don't expect the book to do the teaching for you.

Age Fit

Best for ages 3-6, when the shiny scales are peak entertainment and kids are just beginning to grasp sharing concepts. By age 7-8, most kids have moved on and can start to see the weird message for what it is.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

68

The sharing-makes-you-happy message is well-intentioned, but the execution is problematic. Rainbow Fish only shares after he becomes lonely—not from genuine kindness—and literally gives away pieces of himself (his beautiful scales) to buy friendship. The moral reads more like 'conform and diminish yourself to fit in' than healthy cooperation. It models transactional relationships rather than authentic connection.

Imaginative

72

The shimmering foil scales are genuinely captivating for young kids—tactile, sparkly, visually striking. The underwater setting with colorful fish offers some creative appeal. But the story itself is straightforward and didactic, with little room for open-ended thinking or interpretation. It's more 'look at the pretty pictures' than 'imagine new possibilities.'

Safe

95

Completely safe for young children. No violence, scary content, or inappropriate themes. The underwater world is gentle and the conflict is purely social (being left out). Zero concerns about unexpected content that would upset a preschooler.

Enriching

52

The intended lesson about sharing is undercut by the troubling subtext: you must give away what makes you special to gain acceptance. Rainbow Fish doesn't learn empathy or discover the joy of generosity—he capitulates to peer pressure and literally dismantles himself. For a book that won awards for its 'universal message,' it teaches a surprisingly unhealthy lesson about self-worth and friendship. The entertainment value is carried entirely by the shiny foil.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Those holographic foil scales are legitimately mesmerizing for toddlers and preschoolers—kids will want to touch every page
Opens conversations about sharing, loneliness, and friendship (even if you'll need to do some repair work on the message)
Short and accessible for young attention spans, with beautiful watercolor illustrations
Culturally ubiquitous—your kid will probably encounter it at school or library anyway

⚠

What to Watch For

The core message is genuinely problematic: Rainbow Fish only shares after being ostracized, and he literally tears off his scales to buy friendship
Kids might internalize that they need to diminish what makes them special to be accepted
You'll probably want to have a follow-up conversation about how real friends like you for who you are, not what you give them
Some kids find the initial rejection of Rainbow Fish upsetting

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think the other fish didn't want to play with Rainbow Fish at first? Was that fair?"
"Do you think Rainbow Fish should have had to give away his scales to make friends? What else could he have done?"
"Have you ever felt left out like Rainbow Fish? What helped you feel better?"
"What makes YOU special? Would you want to change that to make friends, or find friends who like you as you are?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Related Guides

Books About Sharing: Building Empathy Through Stories

How children's books about sharing can spark conversations about generosity, friendship, and emotional intelligence.

Writing about The Rainbow Fish? Put this WISE score on your site