Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Cassandra Calin has a gift for capturing the specific brand of 'cringe' that defines the ages of 11 to 13. First Crush doesn't talk down to its audience; it gets in the trenches with them. It’s funny, it’s honest, and it’s exactly the kind of book that turns 'reluctant readers' into 'kids who won't put the book down.'
If your kid is navigating the weird transition where everyone starts acting differently because of hormones and heart-eyes, this is a must-read. It treats the physical and emotional upheavals of puberty as a shared comedy rather than a private tragedy.
Age Fit
Perfect for the 9-14 crowd. If they've already inhaled everything by Raina Telgemeier, this is the logical next step.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
It captures the messiness of middle school with a lot of heart. The relationships with parents and friends are supportive even when they are strained by typical pre-teen drama.
Imaginative
78
While it's a grounded slice-of-life story, Calin's visual storytelling and comedic timing are top-tier. It turns mundane awkwardness into a creative art form.
Safe
96
Extremely safe. It addresses puberty and periods directly but in a way that is age-appropriate and normalizing for the middle-grade audience.
Enriching
92
Excellent for social-emotional learning. It helps kids navigate the confusing transition of seeing friends as romantic interests and handling the physical changes of growing up.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Relatable awkwardness that makes kids feel seen rather than embarrassed.
Normalizes puberty by discussing periods and body changes without the clinical boredom of a health textbook.
High-tier illustration from Cassandra Calin, whose webcomic background means every panel is expressive and funny.
Emotional intelligence is baked into the plot, especially regarding how to handle unrequited feelings and shifting friendships.
⚠
What to Watch For
Period talk is blunt. It’s not 'mature' in a scandalous way, but it’s honest about cramps and the general 'ugh' factor of menstruation.
Crush obsession is the main engine of the plot, which might be a bit much for kids who aren't interested in the romance side of middle school yet.
Conversation Starters
"Lia is so focused on Julien that she misses someone else's crush on her—have you ever realized you were totally missing what was right in front of you?"
"How do you tell the difference between a friend who is helping you and a friend who is just hyping up a crush?"
"Lia’s French is getting better but her social life is getting harder. Which one would you rather deal with?"
"What's the most 'cringe' thing you've seen happen in a middle school hallway lately?"
Deep Dive
The 'Telgemeier Effect' and Cassandra Calin
For a long time, Raina Telgemeier owned the middle-grade graphic novel space with books like Guts and Smile. Cassandra Calin is the natural successor to that throne. What makes First Crush stand out in the 2026 landscape is its roots in webcomic culture. Calin’s art is incredibly expressive—she knows how to draw a 'panic face' or a 'smitten face' in a way that resonates instantly with a generation raised on emojis and visual storytelling.
Why This Sequel Matters
The first book, The New Girl, was about the external struggle of fitting into a new place. First Crush turns the lens inward. It tackles the 'second phase' of middle school: when you’re no longer the new kid, but you’re still trying to figure out who the 'new you' is. The inclusion of period talk is a standout feature. It’s handled with the same matter-of-fact humor that Calin uses for everything else, which does more for a kid's confidence than a dozen 'birds and the bees' talks.
Comparison to the Field
Compared to something like Rex Ogle’s Fruitcake, which can get quite heavy, Calin stays in the 'charming and comical' lane. It’s a lighter read, but no less impactful. It’s the kind of book that will be passed around a friend group until the cover starts to peel. If you’re looking for a bridge between 'little kid' books and 'young adult' fiction, this is the perfect middle ground.