The Magician's Elephant – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

The Magician's Elephant

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

movie2023

68%

WISE Score

Avg. Tomatometer

A whimsical quest involving a conjured elephant and a lost sister—charming premise, middling execution.

66%

→

The Magician's Elephant

movie

PG, 2023

68%

WISE Score

Avg. Tomatometer

A whimsical quest involving a conjured elephant and a lost sister—charming premise, middling execution.

66%

Jump to

Also rated on

66%

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

The Magician's Elephant has a genuinely lovely premise—magical realism meets sibling quest—but the execution lands somewhere between 'nice' and 'forgettable.' The 66% critic score and 53 Metacritic tell the story: it's competent but not inspired.

That said, the 79% audience score suggests kids are more forgiving than film critics (shocker). If your family enjoys gentle animated adventures with heart, this will work for a cozy movie night. Just don't expect Pixar-level emotional devastation or Studio Ghibli-level wonder.

The themes are genuinely good—hope, community, impossible tasks—and it's safe for elementary-aged kids. But in a Netflix library packed with animated options, this one's more 'if you've exhausted everything else' than 'must-watch immediately.' Perfectly fine. Perfectly forgettable.

Age Fit

Best for ages 7-11 who enjoy whimsical adventures and can handle emotionally complex themes about loss and hope. Younger kids (5-6) might follow the plot but miss the deeper resonance; tweens 12+ will likely find it too simplistic unless they're in the mood for something gentle.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

A heartwarming story about a boy searching for his lost sister, centered on themes of hope, perseverance, and community transformation. The quest structure models determination and kindness. Pacing appears balanced for a family adventure. Common Sense Media's age 8 rating suggests emotionally appropriate content, though mixed critical reception (66% RT critics, 53 Metacritic) hints at some tonal inconsistencies that may affect younger viewers.

Imaginative

The premise—finding a magician who conjures an elephant to locate a lost sister—is wonderfully whimsical and fantastical. Three 'impossible tasks' structure invites creative problem-solving. However, the middling Letterboxd score (3/5) and lukewarm critical response suggest the execution may not fully deliver on its imaginative promise. Netflix animated adaptation of a beloved book has potential but may feel derivative of other quest narratives.

Safe

As a Netflix family animated film rated for age 8+, this should be free of graphic content, gore, or inappropriate material. The quest-adventure format is inherently safe for kids. No platform safety red flags (though kids mode isn't available, this is standard for movies). The story involves a lost sibling which could be emotionally heavy for some sensitive kids, but nothing suggests traumatic or shocking content. Deducting points only for potential emotional weight of separation themes.

Enriching

Themes of hope, persistence through adversity, and the power of belief offer meaningful takeaways. The 'three impossible tasks' structure teaches problem-solving and determination. Community transformation suggests broader social impact lessons. However, the mixed reviews (6.6 IMDb, 66% RT critics) indicate the film may not deeply resonate or provide substantial emotional depth. Entertainment value appears moderate based on audience reception (79% RT audience is decent but not stellar).

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Genuinely imaginative premise: find a magician, conjure an elephant, reunite with your sister—it's weird in the best way
Themes of hope and perseverance without being preachy; the 'impossible tasks' structure teaches problem-solving
Emotionally safe adventure that won't traumatize younger viewers, though sibling separation themes add real stakes
Decent audience score (79% on RT) suggests kids enjoy it even if critics were lukewarm

⚠

What to Watch For

The central plot involves a boy believing his sister is dead then discovering she might be alive—could be heavy for kids who've experienced loss or separation
Mixed critical reviews suggest pacing or storytelling issues; some kids may lose interest midway
Not a cultural phenomenon like Encanto or Turning Red—it's fine, but don't expect kids to be quoting it for months

Conversation Starters

"If you could ask a fortune teller one question about your life, what would it be?"
"Peter had to complete three impossible tasks. What's something that feels impossible to you right now?"
"Why do you think the story needed a magician AND an elephant? What do elephants represent?"
"How would you feel if you thought someone you loved was gone, then found out they might still be out there?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic