Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Carola Lovering's Tell Me Lies is a compulsively readable car crash of a novel about obsession, college hookup culture, and emotional toxicity. Following the eight-year entanglement of Lucy Albright and Stephen DeMarco, it digs into the kind of bad relationship that rewires your brain before you even realize you are trapped.
While it reads fast and captures the claustrophobia of young adult obsession with brutal accuracy, this is explicitly adult fiction. Between graphic sexual scenes, gaslighting, alcohol abuse, and an eating disorder subplot, it offers zero fluff or gentle lessons. If your older teen picked this up because of the Hulu series, expect a dark, stressful ride rather than a cozy romance.
Age Fit
Designed strictly for mature audiences (17+). With explicit sexual content, complex emotional toxicity, and dark psychological themes, this is an adult fiction title not intended for younger teens or middle schoolers.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
15
Centers almost entirely on a toxic, emotionally abusive relationship, deceit, betrayal, and unaddressed trauma.
Imaginative
45
Standard contemporary novel format; well-structured dual-perspective narrative, but operates within familiar psychological drama tropes.
Safe
25
Contains explicit sexual content, heavy alcohol use, emotional manipulation, gaslighting, and an eating disorder subplot.
Enriching
40
Offers sharp psychological insights into gaslighting and narcissism, but functions primarily as dark, dramatic entertainment.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Unvarnished look at toxic dynamics: Shows the subtle mechanics of gaslighting and emotional manipulation without romanticizing the harm.
Dual-perspective structure: Alternates between Lucy and Stephen, giving readers a chilling look inside the mind of a master manipulator.
Psychological realism: Captures the messy, obsessive spiral of early adult relationships that are hard to walk away from.
⚠
What to Watch For
Explicit sexual content: Graphic depictions of intimacy and sexual encounters throughout the story.
Heavy psychological triggers: Includes an ongoing eating disorder subplot, intense emotional abuse, gaslighting, and grief.
Dark behavior patterns: Stephen's actions are calculating and borderline sociopathic, making the story uncomfortable at times.
Conversation Starters
"Why do you think Lucy finds it so hard to break away from Stephen, even when she knows he is lying?"
"What are the early warning signs of gaslighting in Stephen's behavior?"
"How does Lucy's unresolved anger toward her mother affect the choices she makes in college?"
Deep Dive
The Mechanics of a Toxic Romance
Tell Me Lies gained massive traction precisely because it refuses to put a glossy spin on terrible choices. Stephen DeMarco isn't a brooding bad boy with a heart of gold—he's an emotionally abusive narcissist who systematically breaks down Lucy's self-esteem while protecting a dark secret from his past. Lovering's alternating narrative forces the reader to watch the trap being set from both sides, making the experience equal parts fascinating and deeply uncomfortable.
For older teens (17+) who might be crossing over from YA into contemporary adult fiction, the book serves as a case study in red flags. It doesn't lecture, but it also doesn't reward the characters for their dysfunction. The relationship is toxic from day one, and the fallout ripples across their entire friend group for years.
Is It Worth the Read?
If you're looking for a dark psychological drama with teeth, Tell Me Lies delivers. Just don't confuse it with a standard romance—it belongs far closer to psychological thrillers like Luckiest Girl Alive. If an older teen in your house is reading it, it opens up very real, grounded conversations about boundary-setting, gaslighting, and how easily emotional manipulation hides behind charisma.