Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the opposite of brain rot. It’s a short, punchy, and genuinely funny chapter book that actually gives kids something to think about regarding how they treat people who see the world differently.
DiCamillo has a way of making simple stories feel significant. It’s high-quality literature disguised as a silly story about a pig and a poem. If you're looking for something to read together at bedtime that won't make you want to pull your hair out from boredom, this is a winner.
Age Fit
Ideal for the 6 to 9 crowd. It’s part of the Deckawoo Drive series, so if they’ve met Mercy Watson the pig, they’re already in.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
95
It’s a Kate DiCamillo book, so it’s basically the gold standard for emotional health. It handles peer conflict with actual nuance rather than just 'everyone be nice' platitudes.
Imaginative
92
The entire plot hinges on the power of metaphor and seeing the world as more than just literal facts. It encourages kids to think outside the 'truth' of what they see right in front of them.
Safe
100
Completely safe. The biggest 'danger' is two kids getting accidentally locked in a school closet, and even that is used as a moment for character bonding rather than scares.
Enriching
94
It manages to teach second-graders about metaphors and the subjectivity of art without being a boring textbook. It builds empathy for different personality types—the dreamer vs. the literalist.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Kate DiCamillo is the GOAT of this age group; she respects kids' intelligence and never talks down to them.
It’s a perfect 'bridge' book for kids who are graduating from picture books but aren't quite ready for 300-page novels.
The conflict between the two main characters—Stella the dreamer and Horace the literalist—is something every kid deals with on the playground.
It makes poetry feel like a superpower rather than a chore.
⚠
What to Watch For
The kids get stuck in a dark closet for a bit, which might bother very sensitive or claustrophobic kids, but it’s handled gently.
Horace Broom is a classic 'know-it-all' who might be a bit grating initially, but that's the point of his character arc.
Conversation Starters
"Why was Horace so upset that Stella's poem wasn't 'true'? Can something be true even if it didn't actually happen?"
"If you had to write a poem about our pet (or a neighbor’s), what’s one impossible thing you’d say they could do?"
"How did being stuck in the closet change how Stella and Horace felt about each other?"
"What does it mean to have an 'anything-is-possible' attitude?"
