Is there actual footage of murders?

Generally, these shows use crime scene photos (often blurred) and dramatic reenactments rather than raw footage of the acts themselves, but the descriptions are explicit and intended to be disturbing.

Is this show educational or just sensational?

It leans heavily toward sensationalism. While there are interviews with experts, the primary goal is to shock the viewer with the 'bizarre' nature of the relationships being profiled.

Can I watch this with my teenager?

Only if they are older (16+) and you are prepared to have a long, serious talk about domestic violence and psychological manipulation. For most families, it's better to skip.

Should I Marry a Murderer? – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Should I Marry a Murderer?

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

show2024

14%

WISE Score

A sensational true crime dive into the dark world of prison romance and the people who seek it out.

Should I Marry a Murderer?

show

2024

14%

WISE Score

A sensational true crime dive into the dark world of prison romance and the people who seek it out.

Jump to

Also rated on

0.0K

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

Look, the title isn't exactly subtle. Should I Marry a Murderer? is pure true-crime bait. If you're into the 'dark side of human nature' subgenre, this is your weekend binge. But for kids? Absolutely not. It’s the kind of content that turns a quiet evening into a deep-seated anxiety about the person living next door.

It’s not 'bad' in the sense of being poorly made, but it’s definitely not for the family living room. It sits in that 2:00 AM 'why am I watching this' category of documentary filmmaking. If your teen is suddenly interested in it, it’s a good time to talk about red flags and how media sensationalizes tragedy.

Age Fit

This is strictly for adults or mature older teens with a strong interest in psychology. There is zero reason for a child to be watching this, as the themes are heavy, dark, and potentially traumatizing.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

The title alone tells the story. This is sensationalist true crime content that centers on extreme violence and questionable life choices. It is the opposite of wholesome—it is designed to shock and disturb.

Imaginative

Likely follows a standard documentary or reality TV formula. While true crime can be well-produced, it rarely invites the kind of creative thinking or world-building we look for in imaginative media.

Safe

Not safe for children or sensitive viewers. Expect graphic descriptions of crimes, discussions of trauma, and potentially disturbing psychological profiles. This is strictly adult territory.

Enriching

While it might offer some insight into criminal psychology or cautionary advice, it’s primarily entertainment-focused sensationalism. It doesn't offer meaningful developmental growth for kids.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Psychological deep dive into the 'hybristophilia' phenomenon—people who are attracted to those who commit crimes.
Cautionary tales that highlight the dangers of extreme parasocial relationships and manipulation.
Gritty realism for fans of the true crime genre who want to see the aftermath of cases rather than just the investigation.

⚠

What to Watch For

Graphic crime details are a given. The show likely recounts specific murders and violent acts in detail.
Emotional manipulation is a central theme, which can be confusing or distressing for younger viewers to process.
Dark psychological themes including domestic abuse, stalking, and narcissism.

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think some people are drawn to dangerous situations or people?"
"How can you tell if someone is being honest with you or just telling you what you want to hear?"
"Where is the line between being supportive and being taken advantage of?"

Deep Dive

The true crime boom of the 2020s has led to some pretty specific niches, and Should I Marry a Murderer? is the logical endpoint of that trend. It moves past the 'who done it' and into the 'why would you date the guy who done it?' territory.

From a parental perspective, the concern here isn't just the violence—it's the normalization of toxic and dangerous relationship dynamics for entertainment. The show explores a very real and very dark corner of human psychology. While it might be fascinating for an adult who can compartmentalize the sensationalism, it lacks the educational framing that would make it 'enriching' for a younger audience. It’s a show that thrives on the 'ick' factor, and while that makes for compelling TV for some, it’s a hard pass for anyone looking for wholesome or safe family content.

What Parents Ask

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic