Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is what good picture books do: take one small, specific childhood experience and handle it with care and honesty. No tricks, no lectures, just a girl who gets stomachaches every Saturday and an instructor who says 'it's okay to sit by the edge this week.'
The magic is in what doesn't happen—Mary never bribes, never shames, never makes it a big deal. She just keeps showing up with patience, and the girl keeps showing up with her fear, until gradually the fear gets smaller. Parents of anxious kids will recognize this dance immediately.
It's not flashy or particularly imaginative, but it's effective and warm. The kind of book you read before a dreaded activity, or after a tough day, or just because your kid needs to hear that taking your time is perfectly fine.
Age Fit
Best for ages 3-7, especially kids currently facing anxiety about swimming, school, or other new activities. The straightforward narrative and clear emotional arc work well for younger picture-book audiences, though older anxious kids might still appreciate seeing their feelings reflected.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
95
Models exceptional patience and kindness through Mary, the instructor who never pushes but gently encourages. Shows adults giving a child the space and time she needs to overcome anxiety without shame or pressure. The watercolor illustrations depict diverse children, and the tone is warm and reassuring throughout.
Imaginative
72
Hyewon Yum's watercolor and colored-pencil illustrations bring the pool environment to life with sensory details—the loud echoes, wet floors, tight swim cap. The visual storytelling captures internal anxiety in a relatable way, though the narrative itself is straightforward and slice-of-life rather than fantastical or particularly inventive.
Safe
100
Completely safe for all ages. No concerning content whatsoever. The book addresses childhood anxiety in a gentle, non-scary way. Web reviews confirm 'no preaching or reproach or trick,' just supportive adults helping a nervous child.
Enriching
88
Directly addresses childhood anxiety about new experiences with a practical, empowering message: it's okay to take your time, and small steps count. Shows that bravery isn't about being fearless—it's about trying despite fear. Valuable for both anxious kids (who see themselves) and confident kids (who learn empathy). The 4.8 Amazon rating suggests strong parent and educator appreciation.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Validates childhood anxiety without making it dramatic—the girl's fear is treated as normal and manageable
Mary the instructor is the MVP: never pushes, never shames, just offers gentle encouragement and options
Shows the reality of gradual progress—no magical overnight transformation, just steady small wins
Watercolor illustrations capture the sensory overload of a pool (loud echoes, wet floors, tight cap) that anxious kids will recognize
Diverse representation in the illustrations without making it a 'thing'
⚠
What to Watch For
This is a quiet, slice-of-life story—kids expecting action or humor might find it slow
Best as a tool for kids currently facing anxiety about something new, less engaging as pure entertainment
The stomachache detail might give some kids ideas (though most anxious kids already know this trick)
Conversation Starters
"Have you ever felt nervous about trying something new? What was it like?"
"What do you think helped the girl finally get in the pool?"
"If you were Mary, how would you help someone who was scared?"
"What's something you want to try but feel a little nervous about?"