Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.

Screenwise Verdict

This is the real deal—a beautifully crafted middle grade novel that doesn't talk down to kids but also doesn't traumatize them. Palacio (Wonder) knows how to balance emotional depth with age-appropriate storytelling.

The premise is immediately gripping: wake up, watch your dad get taken, find a mysterious pony at your door, go rescue him with only a ghost for company. It's atmospheric, mysterious, and deeply moving without being manipulative. The historical setting adds richness, and the magical realism elements (ghost companion, mysterious pony) give it a timeless, fable-like quality.

The emotional intensity is real—this deals with loss, fear, and perilous journeys—but it's handled with care. Think Bridge to Terabithia vibes: it'll make you feel things, but that's the point. Not for kids who need everything light and fluffy, but perfect for those ready for stories with real stakes and moral complexity.

At 4.6 stars on Amazon and described as 'destined to become a classic,' this is one of those books that sticks with you. It's recent enough (2021) to feel fresh but timeless enough in its themes to have staying power.

Age Fit

Best for ages 10-14, though it has crossover appeal for adults who love atmospheric, emotionally rich historical fiction. Younger kids might find the emotional intensity and separation themes too heavy, while confident middle schoolers will appreciate the depth and mystery.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

88

A heartfelt adventure about a boy's quest to rescue his father, with themes of courage, love, and family bonds. The story models determination and loyalty without being preachy. The presence of a ghost companion adds a gentle supernatural element that explores grief and friendship. Parent reviews highlight 'strong core values' and a parent who 'chose love over money.' Emotionally grounded with appropriate stakes for middle grade readers.

Imaginative

85

Blends historical fiction with fantasy elements—a mysterious pony guide and a ghost companion create an atmospheric, magical-realist adventure. Set during a specific historical period (appears to be 1860s based on context), it invites readers into a richly imagined world that mixes the real and unknowable. From the author of Wonder, known for emotionally resonant storytelling. The quest structure and mysterious elements keep readers engaged and guessing.

Safe

78

A book with some intense themes—a father is taken away in the night, leaving a child alone and scared. The journey is described as 'perilous' and likely includes period-appropriate dangers. Death is present (the ghost companion, likely other losses given the historical setting). However, these elements are handled in a middle-grade appropriate way. Parent reviews suggest ages 10-13+, indicating some mature content but nothing gratuitous. No sexual content, profanity, or graphic violence expected, but emotional intensity and loss are central.

Enriching

90

A coming-of-age tale that connects past, future, and 'the unknowable world' around the protagonist. Historical fiction elements provide educational value about the 1860s era. Explores complex themes of loss, courage, family, and moral choices (choosing love over money, choosing change for the better). Reviews call it 'engaging' with depth that rewards older readers and adults. From the author of Wonder, which became a cultural touchstone for empathy education. Described as destined to become a classic.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

From R.J. Palacio (Wonder), so you know it'll hit you right in the feelings—in a good way
Mixes historical fiction with magical realism: a ghost best friend and a mysterious pony guide create an atmospheric, unforgettable journey
Strong themes of family loyalty, moral courage, and choosing love over greed without being preachy about it
Keeps readers guessing with its quest structure—reviewers say it's engaging for older kids AND adults
Rich historical setting (1860s) that educates while entertaining

⚠

What to Watch For

Opens with a scary scene: strangers take the protagonist's father in the night, leaving a 12-year-old alone and terrified
Death and loss are present throughout—the companion is literally a ghost, and the journey is described as perilous
Emotionally intense for sensitive readers; this isn't a light adventure romp
Some parent reviews suggest 13+, though confident 10-year-olds who can handle emotional complexity will be fine

Conversation Starters

"Silas has a ghost as his best friend. If you could have any kind of unusual companion, what would it be and why?"
"The book is about a kid having to be incredibly brave when his dad is taken. What's the bravest thing you've ever had to do?"
"Silas's father 'chose love over money.' Can you think of a time when doing the right thing meant giving something up?"
"The mysterious pony just shows up and Silas knows what to do. Have you ever had a moment where you just knew the right choice, even if it was scary?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Related Guides

Best Equestrian Books for Kids: Building Confidence Through Horse Stories

From Black Beauty to modern favorites, how horse books teach responsibility, empathy, and courage.

why i’m not following screen time guidelines

I don't have screen time limits in our house, but I do have an approach. Here's how we think about screens, slow content, and movie nights.

My Little Pony: Harmony Quest

A colorful, low-stakes adventure for the preschool crowd that hits a hard paywall much sooner than you’d expect.

Writing about Pony? Put this WISE score on your site