Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the book you grab when there's a new baby coming and your preschooler is already side-eyeing the crib. It's gentle, it's smart, and it doesn't talk down to kids.
Keats nails the emotional truth: Peter isn't a brat for being jealous, and he doesn't need a lecture—he needs to feel seen. The ending (he's literally too big for the chair now) is perfect because it lets him save face while choosing generosity.
The art is lovely if you like collage textures, though some modern kids raised on Pixar-level color saturation might find it muted. And yes, it's short—this is a 5-minute read, max. But for what it does, it does beautifully. A classic that actually earns the title.
Age Fit
Perfect for ages 2–7, especially kids about to become (or who recently became) big siblings. The simple text works for toddlers; the emotional content resonates through early elementary. By 8, most kids have moved on.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
92
A gentle, emotionally intelligent story about sibling rivalry that validates a child's feelings while modeling healthy adjustment. Peter's jealousy over his new sister is treated with empathy, not shame. The resolution—Peter realizing he's outgrown his chair and choosing to share—feels organic, not preachy. Models family cooperation and emotional growth without being didactic.
Imaginative
68
Keats' collage illustrations are distinctive and visually interesting, with layered textures that reward close looking. The story itself is straightforward realism—no fantasy elements, no flights of fancy. It invites kids to think about growing up and family dynamics, but doesn't spark the kind of creative play or world-building that higher-scoring imaginative works do. Solid craft, limited scope.
Safe
98
As safe as picture books get. No scary moments, no sad content, no surprises. The 'conflict' is Peter feeling left out, which resolves gently. Keats was groundbreaking for portraying realistic, multicultural urban settings in 1962; this book continues that inclusive tradition. Zero content concerns for any age.
Enriching
85
Excellent for helping kids process big sibling feelings. It normalizes jealousy, validates the impulse to protect what's yours, and shows growth without lecturing. The emotional arc—from resentment to acceptance to generosity—is developmentally spot-on for preschoolers navigating family change. Multiple reviewers cite it as genuinely helpful for families expecting a new baby. High empathy-building value.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Validates jealousy and possessiveness without making kids feel bad about it—Peter's feelings are real and respected
The resolution (he's outgrown the chair anyway) is clever and satisfying, not preachy
Keats' collage art is textured and beautiful, and his multicultural urban settings were revolutionary in 1962—still feel warm and inclusive
Short and simple enough for toddlers, emotionally sophisticated enough to actually help with new-baby transitions
Amazon 4.9 stars; parents consistently say 'this worked' for preparing kids for a sibling
⚠
What to Watch For
This is a quiet, simple story—no wild plot twists, no silliness. Some kids want more action.
The art style is dated (1960s collage) which some modern kids may find less engaging than bright digital illustrations
It's short—like, really short. A few sentences per page. Great for attention spans, less great if you want a longer bedtime read.
Conversation Starters
"Have you ever felt like someone was taking your stuff? What did you do?"
"Peter ran away with his chair. Where would you go if you wanted to be alone for a bit?"
"Why do you think Peter decided to let his sister have the chair in the end?"
"What's something you used to love when you were little that you've outgrown now?"
