Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is one of those rare picture books that does genuine cultural work without feeling like homework. Lailah's anxiety about being the only kid not eating lunch is so relatable—any kid who's felt different will see themselves here, whether they're Muslim or not.
The awards aren't just participation trophies: this book legitimately helps Muslim kids feel seen and gives non-Muslim kids language to understand Ramadan beyond 'that thing where people don't eat.' The illustrations are gorgeous, the problem-solving is age-appropriate, and the tone is warm without being preachy.
It's not a wild adventure story, so entertainment value is moderate, but for what it is—a gentle, important book about belonging and cultural understanding—it absolutely delivers. Every elementary classroom and home library could use this one.
Age Fit
Perfect for ages 5-10, especially kids in elementary school navigating friendships and cultural identity. The Fountas & Pinnell Level N makes it accessible for 2nd-4th grade independent readers, but younger kids will love it read aloud. Older elementary students benefit from the cultural education even if the reading level feels easy.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
94
Gentle, moving story about navigating cultural identity with kindness and understanding. Models respectful friendship-building across differences, shows supportive adults (librarian and teacher), and handles a child's anxiety about fitting in with warmth and care. Emotionally healthy approach to belonging and self-acceptance.
Imaginative
78
Vibrant illustrations with decorative arabesque borders that contrast Islamic patterns with American school life. Creative visual storytelling that introduces unfamiliar cultural practices through a child's perspective. Not wildly inventive in plot structure, but thoughtful in its artistic approach and cultural bridge-building.
Safe
98
Picture book with zero concerning content. Age-appropriate throughout, no violence, scary elements, or mature themes. Addresses a child's social anxiety in the gentlest possible way. As safe as books get.
Enriching
92
Excellent educational value: introduces Ramadan and Islamic fasting practices to non-Muslim children while affirming Muslim children's experiences. Builds empathy and cultural literacy. Multiple awards recognize its social studies value (NCSS Notable Book, ADL Featured Book). Teaches problem-solving and self-advocacy. Fountas & Pinnell Level N makes it accessible for early readers.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Multiple prestigious awards (ALA Notable Book, NCSS Social Studies recognition, ADL featured) signal genuine quality and educational value
Provides mirror for Muslim children navigating American schools and window for non-Muslim kids to understand their classmates
Handles the universal kid anxiety of 'being different' with warmth and practical problem-solving
Beautiful arabesque border illustrations create visual contrast between Islamic traditions and American school life
4.8 stars on Amazon with reviews praising how it helps both Muslim kids explain fasting and non-Muslim kids understand Ramadan
⚠
What to Watch For
Some kids may need context about what fasting means and why people do it—good conversation opportunity
The school setting and social dynamics are very relatable, but the specific cultural content is educational rather than pure entertainment
Conversation Starters
"Have you ever felt different from your friends at school? What helped you feel better about it?"
"Why do you think Lailah was worried about her classmates not understanding? What would you do if a friend wasn't eating lunch?"
"What traditions does our family have that might seem different to other people?"
"How did the librarian and teacher help Lailah? Who are the adults at your school who help when you're worried about something?"