book2024Children's Books, Science Fiction & Fantasy
90%
WISE Score
4.5
Amazon
A wildly imaginative middle-grade fantasy where two kids race across unmapped islands to save dying magical creatures—think Percy Jackson meets Narnia.
Impossible Creatures
book
2024, Children's Books, Science Fiction & Fantasy
90%
WISE Score
4.5
Amazon
A wildly imaginative middle-grade fantasy where two kids race across unmapped islands to save dying magical creatures—think Percy Jackson meets Narnia.
Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the real deal—a beautifully crafted middle-grade fantasy that respects kids' intelligence while delivering genuine adventure and wonder. Rundell has built a world rich enough to get lost in, with illustrations that invite kids to engage beyond just reading the words.
It's not a quick read, but that's a feature, not a bug. This is the kind of book that becomes a favorite, the kind kids will press into their friends' hands and say 'you HAVE to read this.' The combination of imaginative world-building, strong character dynamics, and meaningful themes (without being heavy-handed) is exactly what great middle-grade fiction should be.
If your kid loved Percy Jackson, Nevermoor, or The Girl Who Drank the Moon, this belongs on their shelf.
Best for ages 9-13, particularly kids who've graduated from Magic Tree House but aren't quite ready for full YA. The reading level, length, and complexity suit confident middle-grade readers who love fantasy adventure.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
A classic adventure story with two kids working together to save a magical world. Models cooperation, bravery, and problem-solving. The tone is warm and generous-hearted without being saccharine. No concerning relationship dynamics or mean-spirited content. Emotionally appropriate for middle-grade readers with themes of friendship and heroism.
Imaginative
94
This is where the book absolutely soars. An entire unmapped Archipelago filled with griffins, sphinxes, kraken, and dragons—plus over 60 illustrations including a bestiary and map. Rundell is known for her 'wild imagination' and 'utterly distinctive voice' (per Philip Pullman). The premise of racing island-to-island consulting magical creatures to solve a mystery is peak imaginative adventure. The kind of book that makes kids want to draw their own creatures and maps.
Safe
82
Books are generally safe, and this middle-grade fantasy fits that pattern. Common Sense Media lists it with a recommended minimum age of 9-10. There are adventure elements (battling kraken, creatures dying) but nothing gratuitous or traumatic for the target age. The 'dark truth' mentioned in the synopsis is likely age-appropriate mystery tension rather than genuinely disturbing content. No red flags from parent reviews or safety concerns in search results.
Enriching
86
A #1 NYT bestseller that's substantive enough to be called 'a landmark fantasy series' and praised by The Wall Street Journal as 'brimming with intelligence, inventiveness and generosity of heart.' 368 pages of reading that builds vocabulary, problem-solving skills, and introduces mythology and fantastical creatures. The themes of environmental collapse (magic fading, creatures dying) and taking responsibility to fix problems yourself are meaningful without being preachy. Strong entertainment value combined with real literary merit.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Katherine Rundell's imagination is firing on all cylinders—griffins, sphinxes, kraken, dragons, and an entire unmapped magical Archipelago
Over 60 illustrations including maps and a bestiary (the kind of book kids will pore over and return to)
#1 NYT bestseller with critical praise for its intelligence and heart—this isn't throwaway fantasy
Strong adventure pacing with two likeable protagonists solving a genuine mystery
Themes of environmental responsibility and 'if we don't fix this, no one will' without being preachy
⚠
What to Watch For
At 368 pages, this is a commitment—best for kids who are already confident chapter book readers
Magical creatures are dying and there's a 'dark truth' to uncover, so some melancholy moments (though age-appropriate)
First in a series, so be prepared for requests for book two
Conversation Starters
"If you could design your own impossible creature by combining two animals, what would you create?"
"Why do you think the magic is fading in the Archipelago? What does that remind you of in our world?"
"Mal and Christopher have to save the islands themselves—when have you had to solve a problem without adult help?"
"Which magical creature from the book would you most want to meet, and which would you absolutely avoid?"