Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
If your teen was obsessed with 'If He Had Been With Me,' this is the closure (or further heartbreak) they've been waiting for. It’s not light reading—it’s the kind of book that leaves you staring at a wall for an hour after finishing.
It handles complex, messy teen emotions with more grace than your average Colleen Hoover clone, making it a solid pick for the high school crowd. It's essentially 'BookTok' bait with an actual soul, focusing on the 'what-ifs' that haunt us when we don't speak up.
Age Fit
Best for 14 and up. It’s heavy, romantic, and assumes the reader is mature enough to handle a plot that basically functions as an autopsy of a tragedy.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
72
It deals with messy, honest teen emotions and the fallout of unspoken truths. While heavy on the drama, it prioritizes emotional processing over cheap thrills.
Imaginative
64
Standard contemporary YA realism. The multi-POV structure adds depth to the internal world-building, though it doesn't reinvent the wheel of the romance genre.
Safe
88
Safe for its 14+ target. It contains teen romance, sexual themes, and significant grief, but nothing outside the expected bounds of modern young adult fiction.
Enriching
82
Strong exercise in empathy and perspective-taking. It forces readers to sit with the consequences of their choices and the weight of grief.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Deeply empathetic look at how different people process the same tragedy
The multi-POV structure gives a voice to characters who were side-lined in the first book
Explores the nuance of 'emotional cheating' and the guilt that comes with it
High engagement for teens who usually only read what's trending on social media
⚠
What to Watch For
The plot centers on a major character death; it's an emotional heavy-lifter
Romantic tension involves a protagonist who is already in a committed relationship
Includes typical YA descriptions of physical intimacy and teen 'dating and sex' themes
Conversation Starters
"Why do you think Finn felt like he couldn't be honest with Sylvie or Autumn?"
"How does seeing the story from Jack’s perspective change how you feel about Finn?"
"Is there a difference between being 'in love' with someone and just loving them as a friend?"
"If you knew you only had a limited time with someone, what would you make sure to tell them?"