Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the equivalent of a good parenting manual in picture book form. It's not going to win awards for storytelling or illustration, and your kid probably won't beg you to read it 47 times like they do with 'The Pigeon Wants a Puppy.'
But that's not the point. The point is helping a 3-year-old understand that a screaming potato is about to invade their home, and that this is actually a good thing. On that front, it delivers. The book is gentle, reassuring, and focuses on the positive aspects of siblinghood without being saccharine.
It's sold 4 million copies because it works—parents report that it genuinely helps ease sibling anxiety and sets a positive tone. Read it a bunch in the months before baby arrives, then quietly retire it to the shelf once everyone's adjusted. Functional, effective, and worth the $10.
Age Fit
Perfect for ages 2-5 who are about to become older siblings. After the baby arrives and the transition is complete, this book will likely lose its relevance—it's a pre-baby prep tool, not a long-term library staple.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
92
Written by trusted children's author Joanna Cole (Magic School Bus), this book centers on positive emotions around family transitions. It emphasizes the older sibling's helpful role and frames the new baby as an exciting addition rather than a threat. The tone is reassuring and loving, with an author's note specifically addressing the need for extra guidance and love during this transition. Nearly 4 million families have used this book, suggesting it resonates with parents seeking emotionally healthy preparation.
Imaginative
58
This is a straightforward, informational picture book about becoming an older sibling. While the illustrations are described as 'sweet and engaging,' the book's primary purpose is practical preparation rather than creative exploration. It doesn't invite building, pretend play, or open-ended thinking—it's more of a social-emotional primer. Functional and helpful, but not particularly imaginative.
Safe
98
As a picture book about welcoming a new baby, this is about as safe as media gets. No mature content, no scary elements, no surprises. The subject matter is universal and gentle. The only minor consideration is that it assumes a traditional family structure (Mommy and Daddy), but this is standard for 2010 children's books and wouldn't be shocking or inappropriate for any child.
Enriching
85
This book serves a specific developmental purpose: helping young children navigate a major life transition with empathy and understanding. It builds emotional intelligence by naming feelings, teaches about babies and family roles, and helps kids feel empowered rather than displaced. The 4.8 Amazon rating and bestseller status suggest it genuinely helps families. It's enriching in a practical, life-skills way rather than an academic one, but that's exactly what's needed for this age and situation.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Trusted author (Joanna Cole of Magic School Bus fame) who understands how to talk to young kids
Frames the new baby as exciting rather than threatening, emphasizing the older child's important helper role
Short, simple, and designed for toddler attention spans—you can read it multiple times without losing your mind
The 4.8 Amazon rating and 4M+ copies sold suggest it actually works for anxious soon-to-be siblings
Pairs well with Cole's companion book 'When You Were Inside Mommy' for a fuller pregnancy/birth conversation
⚠
What to Watch For
This is a tool, not entertainment—don't expect your kid to request it at bedtime after the baby arrives
Assumes a traditional 'Mommy and Daddy' family structure (standard for 2010, may feel dated for some families)
Works best when read repeatedly in the weeks/months before baby arrives, not as a one-time read
Conversation Starters
"What are some ways you could help with the new baby? What sounds fun and what sounds kinda boring?"
"Do you think babies are cute or kinda weird-looking? (Spoiler: they're both!)"
"What do you think you'll teach the baby when they get bigger?"
"Were you nervous about anything when we talked about the new baby coming?"
