Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is one of those books every parent eventually needs. It's not flashy or groundbreaking, but it does exactly what it sets out to do: give young kids a gentle, honest introduction to death and grief through the lens of a beloved pet.
The repeated refrain—'I'll always love you'—is the heart of the book, and it's a genuinely useful tool for families. It normalizes expressing affection daily and plants the idea that love persists even after loss. The illustrations are sweet without being cloying, and the pacing feels right for the emotional weight.
Is it a fun read? No. Will it make you cry? Probably. But that's the point. It's a tool, and a good one. Keep it on the shelf for when you need it—whether that's preparing a child for an aging pet, processing a loss, or just opening up conversations about big feelings.
Age Fit
Best for ages 3-8, particularly when a family is preparing for or processing the loss of a pet. Older kids who've experienced loss might still find comfort here, but it's really designed for the early childhood years when death is a new and confusing concept.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
95
A tender, emotionally honest story about the bond between a child and their dog, emphasizing the importance of expressing love daily. The narrative handles grief with warmth and reassurance, showing healthy emotional processing. The repeated 'I'll always love you' refrain models affection and emotional openness without being saccharine.
Imaginative
68
The story follows a straightforward narrative arc of a boy and his dachshund growing up together. While the illustrations by Hans Wilhelm are gentle and expressive, the book doesn't push creative boundaries or invite much interactive imagination. It's more contemplative than inventive, serving its emotional purpose well but not sparking wild creativity.
Safe
92
This is explicitly designed as a gentle introduction to death and loss for young children. While the subject matter involves the dog dying of old age, it's handled with care and warmth—no graphic details, no sudden trauma. Parents know exactly what they're getting into from the synopsis. The only reason it's not 100 is that some very young or sensitive kids might find even this gentle treatment of death sad, but that's the entire intentional point of the book.
Enriching
88
This book does important emotional work. It normalizes grief, models healthy expression of love, and gives kids (and adults) language for processing loss. The message that expressing love daily matters—because you won't always have the chance—is genuinely meaningful. It's a tool for building emotional intelligence and resilience around one of life's hardest topics.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Gives kids a safe, gentle framework for understanding pet death and grief before they experience it firsthand
The daily 'I'll always love you' ritual models emotional expression in a way that feels natural, not preachy
Hans Wilhelm's warm illustrations balance the sadness—Elfie is clearly loved and has a full, happy life
Helps kids (and adults) process that loving someone doesn't mean you won't lose them, and that's okay
Been a trusted resource for parents since 1988, with a 4.7/5 Amazon rating from thousands of families
⚠
What to Watch For
This is explicitly about a dog dying of old age—expect tears, though it's handled as gently as possible
Some kids might need reassurance afterward that their own pets are healthy and not going anywhere soon
The emotional weight might be too much for very sensitive preschoolers; gauge your kid's readiness
Conversation Starters
"Why do you think it was important that the boy told Elfie 'I'll always love you' every night?"
"What are some ways we can show the people and pets we love how much they mean to us?"
"Have you ever felt sad about saying goodbye to someone? What helped you feel better?"
"What do you think the boy will remember most about Elfie?"
