Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Gratitude Soup is a well-intentioned picture book that teaches a genuinely useful emotional skill—pausing to reflect on what you're thankful for. The metaphor of cooking an imaginary soup is sweet, and the book explicitly invites kids to try it themselves.
That said, this is a 2009 self-published title, and it shows. The art is collage-watercolor but feels a bit clunky, the rhyming is workmanlike, and the whole thing reads more like a therapeutic exercise than a story. The 3.7 Amazon rating suggests parents appreciate the intent but find the execution just okay.
If you're looking for a book to introduce gratitude practice, this does the job—but there are probably more engaging, better-crafted options out there. It's fine, not great.
Age Fit
Best for ages 3–7, when kids are just learning to name and manage emotions. Older kids might find it too simplistic or preachy, though the gratitude practice itself is valuable at any age.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
A gentle picture book that models positive emotional habits through Violet the Purple Fairy's practice of gratitude. The metaphor of 'cooking' gratitude soup is warm and age-appropriate, encouraging kids to reflect on what they appreciate. No concerning content, just straightforward emotional wellness teaching.
Imaginative
72
The central metaphor of an imaginary soup pot that shrinks and stays warm in your heart is creative, and the collage-watercolor art style offers visual interest. The book explicitly invites kids to make their own gratitude soup, and there's a companion 'Create Your Own' arts-and-crafts version. However, the concept is fairly straightforward and didactic—it's teaching a specific practice rather than opening up wide imaginative play.
Safe
95
This is a picture book about gratitude with a fairy protagonist. No safety concerns whatsoever—no scary content, no mature themes, no surprises. Entirely predictable and gentle. Books like this are inherently safe.
Enriching
76
The book directly teaches an evidence-based emotional regulation tool (gratitude practice), and the author cites actual research from UC Davis on gratitude's benefits. For a picture book, that's solid enrichment—kids learn a concrete mindfulness technique. However, it's quite didactic and instructional rather than weaving the lesson into a compelling story. PBS Kids featured it as a gratitude resource, which signals educational value. The 3.7 Amazon rating suggests it works okay but isn't a runaway hit.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Teaches a concrete, research-backed emotional tool (gratitude practice) in kid-friendly language
The 'gratitude soup' metaphor is gentle and accessible for young kids learning to name what they appreciate
Companion arts-and-crafts version lets kids create their own gratitude project
PBS KIDS featured it as a gratitude resource, signaling educational credibility
⚠
What to Watch For
Pretty didactic—reads more like a lesson plan than a story, which may lose some kids' interest
Self-published with modest Amazon rating (3.7/5); production quality and art may feel dated or amateurish
The rhyming can be a bit forced, and the fairy framing might feel twee to older or more skeptical kids
Conversation Starters
"What would you put in your own gratitude soup today?"
"Do you think imagining something warm in your heart could actually make you feel better? Why or why not?"
"Who's someone you're grateful for that you haven't told lately?"