Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is one of those preschool staples that actually earns its place on the shelf. It's not fancy—the text is minimal, the concept is straightforward—but the interactive masks genuinely work. Kids love putting on the monster faces and acting out emotions, which turns what could be a preachy 'feelings lesson' into actual play.
The 1997 design is simple bordering on dated, but for this age group, that's fine. Emberley's monsters are bold, bright, and just weird enough to be interesting without being scary. The book does exactly what it promises: gives little kids a concrete, hands-on way to explore and name their feelings.
It's not going to win literary awards, and older kids will outgrow it quickly, but for the 2-5 crowd working on emotional regulation? Solid choice. Just laminate those masks.
Age Fit
Best for ages 2-6, when kids are actively building emotional vocabulary and love interactive elements. The simple format and masks are perfect for toddlers and preschoolers, though it may feel too basic for kids beyond kindergarten.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
92
A gentle, affirming approach to emotions that validates all feelings without judgment. The monster characters make feelings approachable and fun rather than scary or shameful. Models emotional literacy in an age-appropriate, playful way.
Imaginative
88
Die-cut masks and interactive play elements invite kids to physically embody different emotions. Ed Emberley's distinctive bright, bold illustrations create memorable monster characters. The format transforms passive reading into active emotional exploration and dramatic play.
Safe
98
Books about emotions are inherently safe. No concerning content whatsoever. The masks are designed for preschoolers (though reviewers recommend laminating for durability). Zero safety concerns.
Enriching
85
Builds foundational emotional vocabulary and recognition skills—critical for social-emotional development. Helps kids name and normalize a range of feelings. The interactive masks provide concrete practice in identifying emotions, which is genuinely useful for preschool and early elementary ages.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Physical masks let kids literally 'try on' emotions, making abstract feelings concrete and playful
Ed Emberley's bold, colorful monster illustrations are friendly and engaging without being saccharine
Normalizes the full range of emotions—mad, sad, scared, silly—without moralizing about 'good' vs 'bad' feelings
Short, simple text works for toddlers through kindergarten without talking down to them
Masks become props for extended dramatic play beyond just reading the book
⚠
What to Watch For
The 1997 format is basic—this isn't a sophisticated picture book, it's a functional tool
Masks are cardstock, so laminate them if you want them to survive more than a few preschool sessions
Kids who struggle with masks on their faces might resist the interactive element
Conversation Starters
"Which monster feeling did you feel like today? What made you feel that way?"
"Can you show me your silly face? Your mad face? What about when you're feeling loving?"
"The monsters say it's okay to feel mad sometimes. What do you do when you feel mad?"
"Which feeling is hardest for you to talk about? Why do you think that is?"