Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is exactly what it says on the tin: a sturdy board book version of the classic Halloween counting rhyme. It's not trying to reinvent the wheel, and that's fine—sometimes you just need a book that can survive being chewed on while teaching basic counting.
The 4.8 Amazon rating and enthusiastic parent reviews suggest it hits the sweet spot for toddlers: short, rhythmic, repetitive, and durable. The illustrations are cheerful rather than scary, which is perfect for introducing Halloween to little ones who might freak out at actual spooky imagery.
That said, this is firmly in the 'functional and pleasant' category rather than 'instant classic.' It does its job well—teaching numbers, building familiarity with rhyme, offering a seasonal read—but it won't blow anyone's mind. If you've got a 1-3 year old and need a Halloween book that won't terrify them or fall apart after three readings, this is a solid pick. Just don't expect it to have staying power beyond preschool.
Age Fit
Solidly designed for ages 1-3, when board books reign supreme and counting to five feels like a genuine accomplishment. By age 4, most kids will have moved on to longer stories, though it can stick around for nostalgic rereads or younger siblings.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
Classic nursery rhyme adapted into a gentle board book with smiling pumpkins, bouncy rhyming text, and mild Halloween spookiness that's more fun than frightening. Padded covers and rounded corners show thoughtful design for little hands. Tone is joyful and age-appropriate for toddlers.
Imaginative
65
Based on a well-known nursery rhyme, so limited originality, but the counting element and Halloween setting invite basic number recognition and seasonal exploration. Bold illustrations provide visual interest. It's a functional board book but doesn't push creative boundaries—it's more about familiarity than innovation.
Safe
95
Completely safe for the target age group. Mild Halloween themes (pumpkins on a gate, night setting) with no scary imagery—reviews emphasize 'smiling illustrations' and describe it as 'sweet' and 'full of joy.' Board book format prevents paper cuts. Zero concerning content.
Enriching
70
Teaches counting from one to five, introduces rhyme and rhythm, and familiarizes toddlers with Halloween vocabulary and seasonal concepts. The verse structure supports early literacy. However, it's a simple board book—enriching for its age group (1-3) but not deeply educational beyond basic numeracy and phonemic awareness.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Introduces counting 1-5 with a catchy, repetitive rhyme that toddlers can quickly memorize and 'read' along
Gentle Halloween vibes with smiling pumpkins—spooky-lite for kids who aren't ready for actual scary stuff
Padded covers and rounded corners make it genuinely toddler-proof (well, as toddler-proof as anything gets)
Short and sweet—perfect for bedtime or quick reads when patience is thin on both sides
High Amazon rating (4.8/5) suggests parents actually like reading it repeatedly, which matters
⚠
What to Watch For
It's a board book of a nursery rhyme—if you're expecting a plot or character development, you're in the wrong aisle
Kids will outgrow this fast; by age 4 they'll probably be done unless they're reading it to a younger sibling
There are multiple versions of 'Five Little Pumpkins' books—make sure you're getting the edition you want
Conversation Starters
"Can you count the pumpkins with me? Let's point to each one!"
"What do you think the pumpkins are doing on that gate? Where are they going?"
"What sounds does the wind make? Can you make a whooshing sound like the wind in the story?"
"Have you ever seen a real pumpkin? What did it feel like?"
