Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Fairest is a solid middle-grade fantasy with a genuinely good message: you don't have to be conventionally pretty to be worthy, capable, or loved. Aza's journey from self-loathing to self-acceptance is handled with care, and Levine's fairy-tale world-building is competent if not revolutionary.
That said, this book is nearly 20 years old, and it shows. The pacing feels slower than contemporary MG fantasy, and the prose style is a bit more earnest and old-fashioned. Kids who devour modern fantasy series might find it a little dated. But if your tween loves retellings, enjoys introspective heroines, or needs a book that tackles appearance anxiety head-on, this is a safe, enriching pick.
It's not a must-read, but it's a good one—especially for kids navigating the brutal middle-school years when everyone's suddenly obsessed with looks.
Age Fit
Best for ages 9-13, especially kids who love fairy-tale retellings and are ready for themes about self-worth and beauty standards. Younger readers (7-8) could handle it if read aloud, but the introspection might drag for them.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
82
Levine's retelling centers on an 'ugly' protagonist who learns self-worth beyond appearance—a genuinely healthy message. Aza's journey involves palace intrigue and jealousy but models courage, loyalty, and kindness. The tone is emotionally appropriate for middle-grade readers, balancing fairy-tale stakes with real character growth.
Imaginative
76
A Snow White retelling with a clever twist: the heroine's magic is vocal (she can 'throw' her voice), not visual beauty. The Kingdom of Ayortha prizes singing above all, which is a fresh angle. The magic mirror, palace schemes, and fantasy world-building are solid but not groundbreaking—Levine works within familiar fairy-tale scaffolding rather than reinventing it.
Safe
92
This is a middle-grade fantasy with no graphic content, violence, or mature themes. Palace intrigue and a jealous queen create tension but nothing traumatic or triggering. The book explicitly tackles beauty standards and self-image, which could be sensitive for some kids but is handled age-appropriately. Amazon lists it for ages 9-13, and that tracks.
Enriching
78
The core theme—that worth isn't tied to conventional beauty—is valuable, especially for middle-grade girls navigating appearance pressures. Aza's growth from self-loathing to self-acceptance offers genuine emotional insight. The book also explores loyalty, integrity, and courage. It's not deeply literary, but it delivers meaningful takeaways alongside an engaging plot.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Aza is 'ugly' by her kingdom's standards and learns self-worth anyway—a genuinely empowering arc for tweens wrestling with appearance anxiety
The vocal magic twist (throwing her voice) is clever and makes Aza feel capable, not just rescued
Gail Carson Levine (author of Ella Enchanted) knows how to craft fairy-tale retellings that feel familiar but fresh
Palace intrigue, a magic mirror, and a jealous queen deliver classic fantasy stakes without being too dark
Strong 4.5-star Amazon rating and recommended for grades 3-7
⚠
What to Watch For
The book explicitly centers on beauty standards and self-image—Aza internalizes a lot of negative self-talk early on, which could be tough for kids already struggling with body image
Published in 2008, so the pacing and style feel a bit slower and more old-fashioned compared to current middle-grade fantasy
If your kid bounced off traditional fairy tales, this might not hook them—it's a retelling, not a genre-bender
Conversation Starters
"Aza spends a lot of time thinking she's ugly. Have you ever felt like you weren't good enough because of how you look?"
"If you could have one magic ability like Aza's voice-throwing, what would it be and how would you use it?"
"The queen is obsessed with being the most beautiful. Why do you think people care so much about being the prettiest or the best-looking?"
"Aza has to decide whether to help the queen even when it's dangerous. When is it worth taking a risk to help someone, and when should you say no?"
