Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is what good middle-grade fiction looks like in 2025. Jason Reynolds writes with the kind of authentic voice that makes kids feel seen—Genie's endless curiosity, the Brooklyn-to-country culture shock, the complicated family dynamics all ring true.
The book's central question—what does it mean to be brave?—never gets a tidy answer, which is exactly right. Grandpop is brave for living independently while blind, but maybe not brave enough to leave his house. Ernie doesn't want to shoot a gun, and the book validates that choice while still respecting family tradition. It's nuanced in a way that trusts young readers to think.
Not a page-turner for action junkies, but for kids ready to sit with big questions about courage, masculinity, and family expectations, this is gold. The 4.8 Amazon rating and multiple awards aren't flukes—this is a book that sticks with you.
Age Fit
Best for ages 10-14, especially kids ready for more complex emotional themes and moral questions. Reynolds' contemporary voice makes this accessible for reluctant readers who bounce off older 'classics,' but the introspective pacing might lose kids looking for non-stop action.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
Jason Reynolds delivers a warm, authentic family story that explores multigenerational love, vulnerability, and what it means to be brave. The relationship between two Brooklyn brothers and their blind grandfather is tender without being saccharine. The book handles masculinity and coming-of-age with nuance—questioning the traditional 'shoot a gun to become a man' ritual while respecting family tradition. Models healthy curiosity (Genie's endless questions), family bonds, and the courage to be yourself.
Imaginative
78
Reynolds brings fresh perspective to the rural-vs-urban fish-out-of-water story through Genie's inquisitive voice and the magical-realist secret room filled with songbirds and plants that feels 'pulled inside-out.' The exploration of how a blind person navigates the world sparks genuine curiosity. Not a fantasy adventure, but the emotional imagination—understanding courage in different forms, seeing the world through Grandpop's experience—is strong. The writing style is distinctive and contemporary.
Safe
92
Extremely safe for middle-grade readers. The most potentially sensitive element is the gun-shooting rite of passage, but it's handled thoughtfully—Ernie's reluctance is validated, and the book questions rather than glorifies gun culture. No graphic violence, no inappropriate content. Common Sense Media parent reviews confirm it's appropriate for 10+ with mature themes handled age-appropriately. The book addresses disability, family dynamics, and masculinity in ways that open conversation rather than traumatize.
Enriching
86
Award-winning (Schneider Family Book Award, Coretta Scott King Honor) for good reason. Tackles complex themes: redefining bravery, understanding disability without pity, questioning toxic masculinity, navigating family expectations. Genie's questions about how his blind grandfather functions aren't just plot devices—they model genuine curiosity and empathy. The book doesn't provide easy answers about what makes someone brave, which is exactly the kind of moral complexity kids need. Strong Black family representation. Builds emotional intelligence and critical thinking about tradition.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Jason Reynolds writes in an authentic, contemporary voice that connects with kids who find most 'classic' books boring
Challenges traditional masculinity without being preachy—questioning whether shooting a gun really makes you a man
Genie's endless questions about how his blind grandfather navigates life model genuine curiosity and empathy without condescension
Award-winning (Schneider Family Book Award, Coretta Scott King Honor) for its nuanced handling of disability and family
The secret plant-and-bird room is quietly magical, giving the realistic story a touch of wonder
⚠
What to Watch For
The gun-shooting rite of passage is a central plot point—handled thoughtfully, but worth discussing with your kid
Some readers under 10 might find the pacing slow or the themes too mature
Genie asks A LOT of questions (it's his character), which some kids will love and others might find annoying
Conversation Starters
"Genie thinks his Grandpop is so brave, but then realizes he never leaves the house. What do you think bravery really means?"
"Ernie doesn't want to shoot a gun for his 14th birthday. Do you think that makes him less brave? What would you do?"
"How do you think Grandpop feels about being blind? Do you think Genie asks too many questions, or is curiosity a good thing?"
"The book is about becoming a man, but what does 'becoming a man' even mean? Is it different from just growing up?"