If you’ve spent any time on BookTok lately, you’ve seen this book. The cover is adorable—muted oranges, cute illustrations of coffee mugs, and a title that practically screams "I own a chunky knit sweater."

Written by Laurie Gilmore, it’s the first book in the Dream Harbor series. The story follows Jeanie, who inherits her aunt’s pumpkin spice cafe in a small town. She meets Logan, a "grumpy" local farmer who doesn't want anything to do with her or her upbeat personality. It’s the classic "grumpy vs. sunshine" trope that is currently dominating the romance genre.

It’s marketed as a "cozy romance," which is a subgenre designed to make the reader feel warm, safe, and happy. Think of it as the literary equivalent of a warm blanket. However, "cozy" in the book world doesn't always mean "PG."

Teens are obsessed with this book for the same reason we all get excited when the temperature drops below 70 degrees: The Aesthetic.

Ask our chatbot about other viral BookTok trends

Here is where we need to be real. In the world of romance novels, there is a spectrum of "spice" (sexual content).

The Pumpkin Spice Cafe is Open Door.

While the first half of the book is a slow-burn romance with lots of flirting and "will-they-won't-they" tension, the second half features multiple explicit sexual encounters. It’s not "erotica," but it’s definitely more graphic than your average Young Adult (YA) novel.

The disconnect for parents is often the cover art. A few years ago, spicy books had covers with shirtless men and Fabio-style hair. Today, the trend is "cartoon covers"—bright, illustrated, and innocent-looking. This makes it incredibly easy for a 13-year-old to pick up a book in Target thinking it’s a sweet story, only to be hit with graphic content 150 pages in.

So, is it appropriate? That depends on your family's boundaries, but here’s the Screenwise breakdown:

Not Recommended. This is a "New Adult" or Adult Romance book, not YA. The sexual content is likely too mature for this age group, and the themes of adult life (running a business, inheriting property) aren't particularly relatable to a middle schooler anyway.

Parental Discretion. If your teen is already reading titles like The Summer I Turned Pretty or It Ends With Us, they’ve likely encountered this level of content. It’s a good time for a conversation about the difference between fictional romance and real-life relationships.

Generally Okay. At this age, most teens are navigating complex themes in school and media. The Pumpkin Spice Cafe is a relatively "safe" version of an adult romance—there’s no dark trauma, violence, or toxic abuse, which is more than you can say for other viral hits like Icebreaker.

Learn more about the "cartoon cover" trend in publishing

If your teen wants that small-town, autumnal feeling without the explicit scenes, these are fantastic alternatives that hit the same notes but stay within the YA boundaries:

This is a gold standard for YA rom-coms. It’s funny, sweet, and focuses on a protagonist who is obsessed with classic rom-com tropes. It’s "closed door" and perfect for ages 13+.

Ali Hazelwood is famous for her adult "STEMinist" romances, but this was her first foray into YA. It’s about competitive chess, has a great "rivals-to-lovers" vibe, and is much more age-appropriate than her adult titles.

If they want the vibe of a small town where everyone knows your name and the coffee is always flowing, you can't beat the original. It’s the ultimate "mother-daughter" watch for the fall season.

Wait, isn't this the same author? Yes. If your teen does end up reading The Pumpkin Spice Cafe and likes it, they will likely want the sequel. Just know that the rest of the Dream Harbor series follows the same "spicy" formula.

If you see this book on your teen's nightstand, don't panic. It’s not "brain rot," and it’s not going to ruin them. Romance novels are a gateway to reading for millions of people.

Instead of banning it, try these conversation starters:

The Pumpkin Spice Cafe is a fun, escapist read that perfectly captures a specific seasonal mood. It is not written for children or young tweens. It is an adult romance novel with explicit sexual content.

If you have an older teen who is a prolific reader, this is likely a "fine" addition to their shelf, provided they understand that fictional romance is often highly stylized and unrealistic. For younger teens, stick to the YA section where the vibes are just as cozy but the "doors" stay firmly closed.

Check out our full guide on navigating BookTok as a parent

Next Steps: