Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the rare celebrity book that doesn't feel like a cash grab. Bob Odenkirk wrote these poems with his kids decades ago to inspire them to create, and you can feel that genuine warmth on every page. The poems are legitimately funny and weird—think Shel Silverstein meets Better Call Saul's dad humor—with Erin's illustrations adding just the right touch of whimsy.
The potty humor is real but not excessive, and Common Sense Media is right that it's best for early readers rather than toddlers. If your kid thinks 'zilot' (a blanket fort) is the coolest made-up word ever and giggles at dogs with the zoomies, this is a winner. It's not going to teach profound life lessons, but it will make bedtime reading fun and maybe inspire your kid to write their own silly poems.
Solid addition to any family bookshelf, especially if you're tired of the same old bedtime rotation.
Age Fit
Best for ages 5-10, when kids can appreciate wordplay, nonsense verse, and potty humor without needing constant explanations. Toddlers will miss the jokes, and tweens will likely age out unless they're nostalgic poetry fans.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
82
A father-daughter collaboration born from bedtime reading traditions, with poems that are 'mostly silly, sometimes poignant.' Common Sense Media notes readers will 'feel uplifted' after reading. Some potty humor present but described as good for families who aren't squeamish. The origin story—Bob writing these with his kids to show them real people make books—models creative collaboration and family connection beautifully.
Imaginative
88
Poetic nonsense in the tradition of Shel Silverstein and Jack Prelutsky, featuring made-up words (like 'zilot' for a blanket fort), whimsical subjects, and Erin's detailed linework that brings the poems alive. Over 70 poems covering everything from dogs with zoomies to how umbrellas work. The book itself was created to inspire kids to become writers and illustrators—literally modeling creative expression. BookPage praised the 'authentic whimsy' and 'jovial yet gentle illustrations.'
Safe
88
Common Sense Media notes it's 'a little much for toddlers' and mentions potty humor that's 'best for families who aren't squeamish,' but no serious content warnings. As a poetry book, there are no surprise violent scenes, scary moments, or inappropriate content—just some bathroom jokes. The 4.7 Amazon rating and bestseller status suggest broad family appeal without major concerns.
Enriching
79
Poetry builds language skills, rhythm, and wordplay appreciation. The made-up words and nonsense verse encourage linguistic creativity. The father-daughter collaboration story adds meta-value about creative process and family projects. However, as 'mostly silly' content, it's more about joy and play than deep themes or lessons—which is perfectly fine for a poetry collection but caps the enrichment ceiling. Common Sense Media says it's 'fun bedtime reading for early readers.'
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Authentic father-daughter collaboration that started as homemade bedtime reading—the origin story is as sweet as the poems
Perfect for kids who love Shel Silverstein's wordplay and silliness, with over 70 poems ranging from hilarious to surprisingly poignant
Erin's whimsical illustrations bring the nonsense to life with soft colors and detailed linework
Encourages kids to see themselves as future writers and creators—the whole point was showing that real people make books
New York Times bestseller that actually earned it with charm, not celebrity cash-in vibes
⚠
What to Watch For
Potty humor throughout—if your family groans at fart jokes, this might not be your jam
Common Sense Media says it's 'a little much for toddlers,' so aim for early readers (5+) who can appreciate the wordplay
Some poems are poignant but most are pure silly—don't expect deep life lessons, just joyful nonsense
Conversation Starters
"What's your favorite made-up word in this book? Should we invent our own word for something in our house?"
"If you could write a poem about anything, what would it be? Want to try writing one together?"
"Which illustration made you laugh the most? What do you think was hardest for Erin to draw?"
"Bob wrote these poems when his kids were little. Do you think we should make our own family book someday?"
