When He Was Wicked – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

When He Was Wicked

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book2017

64%

WISE Score

Francesca’s turn in the Bridgerton spotlight is the series’ steamiest entry—less garden party, more 'I’ve loved you since you were married to my cousin.'

When He Was Wicked

book

2017

64%

WISE Score

Francesca’s turn in the Bridgerton spotlight is the series’ steamiest entry—less garden party, more 'I’ve loved you since you were married to my cousin.'

Jump to

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

If you’re coming here because you loved the pastel-colored vibes of the first few Bridgerton stories, be warned: When He Was Wicked is the moodiest sibling in the bunch. It’s the one that swaps the ballroom banter for intense pining and some of the most explicit scenes Julia Quinn has ever written.

It’s a great book—arguably one of the best in the series—but it’s definitely not for kids. It handles topics like grief and the struggle to conceive with a seriousness that might surprise you. For an older teen who is already deep into romance novels, it’s a high-quality pick, but for anyone else, it’s a 'check the spice level' situation.

Age Fit

This is for the 16+ crowd. While younger teens might be watching the Netflix show, the source material here is significantly more graphic and the emotional themes are geared toward an adult perspective.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

While it centers on a deep, committed love, the 'rake' archetype and the focus on intense physical passion lean more toward adult escapism than traditional wholesome values.

Imaginative

Standard Regency romance tropes done exceptionally well, but it doesn't break new ground or invite the kind of creative exploration seen in other genres.

Safe

This is widely considered the 'steamiest' book in the Bridgerton series. It contains explicit sexual content and mature themes involving grief and infertility that aren't suitable for younger readers.

Enriching

Surprisingly deep exploration of survivor's guilt, the complexity of widowhood, and the emotional toll of infertility. It offers more psychological weight than your average bodice-ripper.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Emotional depth that goes beyond the usual Regency fluff, specifically dealing with the heavy lifting of grief and moving on.
Michael Stirling is arguably the most beloved 'hero' in the series for fans who like the pining, tortured-soul vibe.
Julia Quinn's wit remains sharp, providing the necessary levity to balance out the book's darker, more mature tone.
Infertility representation is handled with a level of nuance and historical accuracy that was rare for the genre when it was first published.

⚠

What to Watch For

Explicit sex scenes are frequent and much more descriptive than in the earlier Bridgerton books; this is firmly adult fiction.
Heavy themes including the sudden death of a spouse and the subsequent survivor's guilt can be a lot for readers looking for a light beach read.
Medical trauma related to malaria and 19th-century 'cures' adds a layer of physical intensity to the middle of the book.

Conversation Starters

"How does Michael's guilt over loving his cousin's wife affect the way he treats Francesca?"
"Does the book change how you think about the pressure women in the 1800s felt regarding having children?"
"Why do you think Francesca felt the need to leave London and her family to find herself?"
"Is Michael's 'rake' persona a mask for his feelings, or just part of who he is?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic