Is Unnatural Creatures too scary for an 8- or 9-year-old?

Yes, for most kids that age. While the premise sounds like a fun creature feature, several stories lean into psychological dread, unsettling monsters, and dark atmospheres. It is much better calibrated for readers 12 and up.

Are all sixteen stories in Unnatural Creatures written by Neil Gaiman?

No. Neil Gaiman wrote the introduction, selected the stories, and contributed one story of his own. The rest are written by fantasy authors including Diana Wynne Jones, Samuel R. Delany, Nnedi Okorafor, and Peter S. Beagle.

Does Unnatural Creatures have content warnings for violence or romance?

There is no explicit violence, gore, or sexual content. Expect dark fantasy themes, creepy monsters, and occasional mild teenage romance or suggestive banter in a couple of contemporary stories.

Is this anthology a good choice for a reluctant reader?

Yes. Short story collections work well for reluctant readers because each story offers a complete narrative in 15 to 30 pages. If a kid doesn't connect with one writer's style, they can jump straight to the next entry.

Unnatural Creatures – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Unnatural Creatures

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

bookJuvenile Fiction

88%

WISE Score

Neil Gaiman gathers sixteen stories about griffin, manticores, and bizarre beasts in an anthology that spans classic and modern fantasy.

Unnatural Creatures

book

Juvenile Fiction

88%

WISE Score

Neil Gaiman gathers sixteen stories about griffin, manticores, and bizarre beasts in an anthology that spans classic and modern fantasy.

Jump to

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. As an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns from qualifying purchases, so if you buy a book or game through one of our links, we may earn a commission. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

If your kid's fantasy diet consists entirely of multi-volume epic series, Unnatural Creatures is a great palate cleanser. Curated by Neil Gaiman and Maria Dahvana Headley, this sixteen-story anthology brings together classic and modern fantasy writers around a single prompt: strange, uncategorizable beasts that never made it into natural history museums.

It works as a high-caliber literary sampler featuring masters of the genre like Diana Wynne Jones, Samuel R. Delany, and Nnedi Okorafor. The tone ranges from lighthearted and bizarre to genuinely eerie and atmospheric, making it a stellar pick for young readers who love dark fantasy.

Because a few stories dip into unsettling psychological horror or light teenage romantic themes, it lands best with middle schoolers and young teens. For kids ready to move past straightforward monster stories into weirder territory, this collection delivers.

Age Fit

Best for ages 12 and up. While published under juvenile fantasy, the creeping atmospheric dread and occasional teen-oriented subtexts in a few tales fit middle schoolers and teens far better than elementary kids.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Atmospheric and creepy at times, with dark fantasy themes and occasional mild teen romantic subtexts, but overall grounded in high-quality storytelling.

Imaginative

An exceptional showcase of legendary mythical beasts, manticores, and bizarre creatures crafted by top-tier fantasy authors.

Safe

As a short story collection, safety is high. Some stories contain eerie imagery and menacing monsters, but there is no explicit content or gore.

Enriching

Exposes young readers to diverse prose styles from genre giants like Diana Wynne Jones and Samuel R. Delany, with royalty proceeds benefiting literacy non-profit 826DC.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Stellar author roster featuring fantasy legends like Diana Wynne Jones, Peter S. Beagle, Samuel R. Delany, and Nnedi Okorafor.
Spans varied styles, mixing whimsical childhood favorites with eerie modern dark fantasy.
Proceeds support literacy through Dave Eggers' creative writing non-profit, 826DC.
Great entryway to short fiction, allowing young readers to sample classic and contemporary authors without committing to full multi-volume series.

⚠

What to Watch For

Menacing tones: Several stories tilt toward dark fantasy, eerie atmospheres, and unsettling creatures that might spook younger or sensitive readers.
Mild teen themes: A few entries touch on adolescent dating dynamics, light innuendo, or suggestive banter suitable for middle schoolers but less ideal for elementary kids.

Conversation Starters

"Which creature in the collection felt the most terrifying or bizarre to picture?"
"If you could adopt one non-traditional mythical beast from these stories, which one would you pick?"
"Did you prefer the funnier, lighter tales or the atmospheric, dark ones?"

Deep Dive

A Masterclass in Genre Short Fiction

Anthologies for young readers often suffer from filler, but Neil Gaiman's curated lineup avoids that trap by leaning into literary voice. Instead of sticking strictly to traditional dragons or well-worn Greek myths, Unnatural Creatures highlights manticores, sunbirds, and strange, unnamable horrors that lurk in the margins.

The real benefit for a young reader is exposure to distinct storytelling styles. A reader might jump from Diana Wynne Jones's sharp British wit to Samuel R. Delany's dense, immersive prose, or Nnedi Okorafor's vibrant, culturally grounded fantasy. It functions as an introduction to genre heavyweights without demanding a commitment to a seven-book series.

Intensity and Age Calibration

While marketed in some spaces as middle-grade, the atmosphere leans heavily into Gaiman's signature creeping dark fantasy. Stories like Gahan Wilson's contribution or Saki's classic tales have bite—characters face real peril, and the monsters aren't always tame or misunderstood. A couple of modern entries also touch casually on teen dating and light subtext, making 12 or 13 the ideal starting floor.

What Parents Ask

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Related Guides

Borges for Beginners: Sophisticated Short Stories for the Deep-Thinking 5th Grader

Move past the "chapter books" with a curated list of accessible, high-concept literature that treats your child like the intellectual they’re becoming.

Books if you like Dave Eggers

Discover moving stories about animals and unique characters that capture the same spirit of wonder, friendship, and philosophical depth found in The Eyes and the Impossible.

Writing about Unnatural Creatures? Put this WISE score on your site