1930
WISE Score
Amazon
Tintin’s awkward first outing is a black-and-white propaganda trip that’s more interesting to historians than actual kids.
4.5
Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)
This is the 'pilot episode' that you usually tell people to skip. Hergé was basically a teenager when he wrote this, and it shows.
It’s messy, it’s political, and the art is a far cry from the gorgeous panels we see in later Tintin adventures. If your kid is obsessed with Tintin, they'll want to see where it started, but don't expect them to finish it. For everyone else, start with 'The Blue Lotus' or 'Cigars of the Pharaoh' and leave this one in the archives.
Technically fine for ages 9 and up, but realistically, most kids will find the black-and-white art and dated politics totally boring. It's really for adult collectors.
While it features a plucky protagonist and his dog, the tone is rooted in 1930s political propaganda. It lacks the emotional depth and 'good vibes' found in later volumes, focusing instead on mocking 'the enemy' through crude slapstick.
Hergé hadn't yet developed his signature style or world-building skills. The plot is a disjointed series of chases and crashes rather than a cohesive, imaginative world.
The violence is pure cartoon slapstick—bombs go off and characters just get soot on their faces. However, the heavy-handed political caricatures and stereotypes of Russians make it an awkward read for a modern child without context.
Beyond being a historical curiosity for comic book fans, there isn't much here. It doesn't offer the cultural exploration or ethical dilemmas that make later Tintin books great.
Get a personalized guide on any topic
