Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

The Wilds had potential with its diverse cast and feminist angle on the survival genre, but it's ultimately a mixed bag. The premise—adults deliberately stranding and traumatizing teenage girls as a social experiment—is deeply unsettling and undercuts any wholesome messaging about female empowerment.

The show earns decent critical scores (89% on RT) for its performances and production quality, but let's be real: it's more interested in shock value and mystery-box plotting than genuine character growth. The dual timeline structure works well for keeping you hooked, but the payoff is uneven.

Biggest issue? Amazon cancelled it after Season 2 with major storylines unresolved, so you're investing in a story that goes nowhere. Add in the mature content—sexual situations, substance use, psychological trauma—and this is strictly for older teens (16+) who can handle dark themes.

If your teen loved Lost or Yellowjackets and can handle mature content, they might enjoy it. But know what you're getting into: it's not empowering survival drama, it's manipulative trauma porn with good cinematography.

Age Fit

This is firmly 16+ territory despite the teen protagonists. The mature content (sexual situations, psychological manipulation, substance use) and dark premise make it inappropriate for younger teens. Older teens who can handle complex, sometimes disturbing themes might find it engaging, but parents should know it's not a light watch.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

45

Teen survival drama with significant interpersonal conflict, manipulation, and psychological tension. While it explores themes of resilience and female friendship, the premise involves deliberately stranding girls as part of a social experiment, which undermines wholesome values. Characters face trauma, betrayal, and morally complex situations that skew darker than emotionally healthy.

Imaginative

72

Strong premise that blends Lost-style survival with YA mystery and a feminist twist. The dual timeline structure (island survival + flashbacks revealing each character's backstory) creates narrative complexity. The reveal of the social experiment adds a layer of intrigue, though execution leans more toward dramatic twists than genuine creative exploration.

Safe

38

Common Sense Media rates this 15+ for good reason. Contains mature themes including sexual content, substance use, violence, and psychological manipulation. The premise itself involves deliberately traumatizing teenage girls. Expect LGBTQ+ relationships (positive representation but intimate scenes), injuries, peril, strong language, and heavy emotional content including references to eating disorders, family dysfunction, and abuse. Not suitable for younger teens.

Enriching

58

Offers diverse female characters with depth and complexity, exploring themes of survival, identity, trauma, and female solidarity. Strong LGBTQ+ representation. However, the manipulative premise and focus on dramatic tension over genuine growth limits its enriching potential. More about shock value and mystery than meaningful life lessons, though character development does provide some emotional insight.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Diverse cast with complex female characters who aren't one-dimensional stereotypes
Strong LGBTQ+ representation woven naturally into the narrative
Mystery box structure keeps you guessing with dual timelines and character backstories
Explores real issues teens face: identity, trauma, family dysfunction, sexuality
High production values and solid performances from young cast

⚠

What to Watch For

Mature sexual content including intimate scenes between teens
Psychological manipulation and trauma as core plot device—the adults are deliberately harming kids
Violence, injuries, substance use, strong language throughout
Heavy themes: eating disorders, abuse, self-harm references
Series was cancelled after Season 2 with major unresolved plotlines—frustrating ending

Conversation Starters

"The show's premise involves adults deliberately traumatizing teens for an experiment. How does that sit with you? Is there ever a justification for that?"
"Each character has a complicated backstory that explains their behavior. Do you think understanding someone's trauma excuses their actions?"
"The show explores female friendship under extreme pressure. What do you think makes or breaks trust in relationships?"
"If you were stranded, what skills do you think would actually be useful versus what we see in movies?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic