Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is exactly what middle-grade fiction should be: funny, fast, and surprisingly thoughtful. Jennifer L. Holm nails the balance between goofy (a world-famous scientist raiding the fridge and dealing with body odor) and meaningful (what does it mean to live a good life, not just a long one?).

The science fair partnership between Ellie and her grandpa-turned-teen is genuinely sweet without being saccharine, and the stakes feel real even though we're talking about mushroom-based immortality formulas. When Jonas Salk the cat gets sick, the story shifts from theoretical to urgent in a way that'll resonate with any kid who's loved a pet.

It's also a godsend for reluctant readers—short chapters, snappy dialogue, and enough humor to keep pages turning. You don't need to love science to enjoy this, though it might spark some curiosity about biology and ethics. At 4.8 stars on Amazon and glowing reviews from parent-focused sites, this is a safe bet for a wide range of kids. Just maybe read The Fourteenth Goldfish first to get the full experience.

Age Fit

Ideal for ages 8-12, especially kids who like funny, character-driven stories with a sprinkle of science. The reading level is accessible for third graders but the humor and themes have enough depth to keep sixth graders engaged. Not much here for teens unless they're reading it aloud to younger siblings.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

88

Heartwarming intergenerational relationship between Ellie and her scientist grandpa (now a teen), models cooperation through their science fair partnership, explores themes of family bonds and acceptance. Common Sense Media notes it encourages openness to new experiences and understanding that failure is OK. The tone is consistently positive and age-appropriate with humor woven throughout.

Imaginative

85

Creative premise of a world-renowned scientist trapped in a teenager's body keeps things fresh and unpredictable. The science fair project exploring eternal youth formulas invites curiosity about real scientific concepts while maintaining a fantastical edge. The 'believe in the unexpected' tagline captures the book's embrace of wonder and discovery, though it's more character-driven than world-building focused.

Safe

95

Extremely safe middle-grade fiction with no concerning content. The stakes involve a sick cat and scientific experimentation, but handled age-appropriately. No violence, mature themes, or surprising dark turns. Common Sense Media confirms it's hilarious and heartwarming without red flags. Books in this genre and by this author (Jennifer L. Holm, known for Babymouse series) are consistently child-friendly.

Enriching

82

Explores meaningful themes about mortality, the pursuit of happiness versus longevity, and what truly matters in life. The science fair framework introduces scientific thinking and experimentation. Tackles ethical questions about eternal youth in an accessible way. Multiple reviews note it's perfect for reluctant readers—concise and engaging—which has real educational value. The question 'is the key to eternal life really the key to happiness?' provides genuine philosophical depth for the age group.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Hilarious fish-out-of-water premise: a brilliant scientist navigating middle school in a 14-year-old body with stinky feet
Tackles big questions (eternal life vs. happiness) in a way that's thoughtful but never heavy-handed
Perfect gateway for reluctant readers—fast-paced, funny, and under 200 pages
Strong intergenerational bond shows kids and 'adults' can be genuine partners and friends
Science fair plot makes STEM concepts feel exciting and accessible, not textbook-y

⚠

What to Watch For

The cat gets sick, which could be emotional for sensitive animal-loving kids (though handled gently)
Works as a standalone but you'll get more out of it if you've read The Fourteenth Goldfish first
Some kids might find the pacing too quick or want more detailed world-building—this is lean and focused

Conversation Starters

"If you could live forever, would you want to? What would be the best and worst parts?"
"Grandpa Melvin is super smart but also kind of awkward at school. Do you think being smart makes middle school easier or harder?"
"If Jonas Salk (the cat) could talk, what do you think he'd say about being part of a science experiment?"
"The book says 'believe in the unexpected.' What's something unexpected that turned out to be really good for you?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

The Third Mushroom