Young Adult Fiction
WISE Score
A Swiftie-coded YA romance set on Martha's Vineyard where an 18-year-old uses her grandmother's memory box to process dementia and a low-spice love story.
Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
If your teen is looking for a cozy, coastal YA romance that hits deep emotional beats without veering into spicy territory, K.L. Walther delivers exactly what is promised. Set against Martha's Vineyard, the story pairs a sweet second-chance romance with a surprisingly realistic look at how families navigate a grandparent's dementia.
It is a low-stress, engaging book that gives high schoolers plenty of heart and nostalgia without requiring parents to pre-screen for explicit scenes.
Best for high schoolers aged 14 to 18. The romance is strictly low-spice and closed-door, but the themes around college transitions and grandparental dementia fit older teens best.
Offers a sweet, closed-door romance centered on family loyalty and intergenerational love, though it includes realistic teen party scenes with alcohol.
Uses a nostalgic memory-box mechanism on Martha's Vineyard to weave past and present narratives together.
Low-spice with no explicit sexual content. Contains mild swearing and minor underage drinking at teen summer parties.
Explores the reality of a grandparent's dementia, processing anticipatory grief, and balancing independence with family care.
Finding YA contemporary romance that skips explicit content without talking down to high schoolers is tougher than it should be. K.L. Walther hits a clear sweet spot here: high emotional engagement, coastal aesthetics, and believable relationship tension while keeping the romance strictly closed-door.
What lifts The Summer of Second Chances above a standard beach read is its core engine: Olivia's relationship with her grandmother, Annie. Rather than using dementia as a background prop, the story grounds Olivia's fear of the future in her daily commitment to holding onto present moments with Annie. Recreating an old photo album across Martha's Vineyard gives the plot a clear spine, making the second-chance romance with Connor feel like a natural extension of Olivia's personal growth.
"Olivia's decision to recreate her grandmother's island memories keeps the story anchored in family identity rather than just teenage pining."
This is an easy hand-off for readers aged 14–18 who like character-first storytelling, New England summer settings, and emotional depth. Parents don't need to worry about surprise spice, though teens will encounter typical high school transition moments, including casual party drinking and mild profanity.
Get a personalized guide on any topic
