Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is a fantastic pick for a kid who wants a story with some actual meat on its bones. It’s not a 'fun, breezy' read, but it’s not a total downer either.
It manages to be smart about science and even smarter about how families deal with things that feel broken. If your kid is aging out of 'baby' books but isn't ready for the high-octane drama of YA, this is the sweet spot.
Age Fit
Perfect for the 10-12 crowd (grades 5-7). Younger kids (8-9) can handle it if they're strong readers or if you're reading it with them, but the emotional nuances of depression might fly over their heads.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
It handles a heavy topic—a parent's clinical depression—with a lot of grace. It models supportive friendships and a teacher who actually cares, without feeling like a 'very special episode' or being overly saccharine.
Imaginative
82
The book uses the scientific method as a literal framework for Natalie's life. The egg drop contest is a great hook that makes science feel like a tool for solving messy human problems rather than just a school subject.
Safe
95
It's a middle-grade novel, so it's inherently safe from the 'brain rot' or 'surprise violence' categories. The only 'danger' is the emotional weight of seeing a parent struggle to get out of bed, which might be a trigger for some kids.
Enriching
92
This is top-tier for emotional intelligence. It gives kids a vocabulary for mental health while sneaking in some solid STEM enthusiasm. It’s the kind of book that makes a kid feel seen if their own home life isn't perfect.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
It treats science as a cool, practical way to look at the world, not just a boring textbook requirement.
The friendship between Natalie, Twig, and Dari is genuinely funny and supportive.
It provides a very realistic, non-scary way to talk about mental health with kids who might be noticing 'sadness' in the adults around them.
Tae Keller’s writing is sharp and modern—it doesn't talk down to middle-schoolers.
⚠
What to Watch For
The mom’s depression is the core of the book; if your family is currently in the thick of a mental health crisis, this might hit a little too close to home.
Natalie and her friends do a bit of 'investigative' trespassing and sneaking around to get what they need for their project.
Conversation Starters
"Why do you think Natalie treats her mom's depression like a science experiment?"
"If you had to design an egg drop container, what's the one thing you'd definitely include?"
"How do Natalie's friends help her even when they don't totally understand what she's going through?"
"What did you think about the 'miracle' Natalie was looking for vs. the reality she found?"