Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

The Polar Express is the real deal—a genuine classic that's earned its place in the Christmas canon. Van Allsburg's illustrations are hauntingly beautiful, and the story has a quiet, almost melancholy magic that sets it apart from more commercial holiday fare.

That said, this is not a book for every kid. It's slow, dreamy, and contemplative in a way that will either enchant or bore, depending on temperament. If your child needs constant action and bright colors, they might not connect. But if they're the type to stare out the window and wonder, this will hit differently.

The belief-in-Santa theme is central, so if your family doesn't do Santa or is in that awkward transition phase, it might feel off. But even beyond the Santa stuff, there's something deeper here about holding onto wonder and magic as we grow up—a theme that resonates well beyond Christmas.

The 40th anniversary edition is gorgeous, and at 4.9 stars on Amazon with glowing parent reviews, it's clear this book still works. Just know what you're getting: a beautiful, atmospheric mood piece, not a rip-roaring adventure.

Age Fit

Best for ages 4-10, though it can work younger if read aloud with a patient kid. The contemplative pace and abstract themes resonate most with children old enough to grapple with belief vs. skepticism. Teens and adults often revisit it nostalgically, but it's primarily a children's book.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

92

Chris Van Allsburg's classic captures the magic and wonder of Christmas Eve with warmth and sincerity. The story follows a boy's journey to the North Pole, emphasizing belief, wonder, and the quiet joy of childhood. No cynicism, no meanness—just a gentle, contemplative tale about holding onto magic. The tone is reverent without being preachy, and the emotional pacing is calm and reflective.

Imaginative

88

The premise itself—a mysterious train arriving at midnight to whisk children to the North Pole—is pure imagination fuel. Van Allsburg's distinctive, atmospheric illustrations create a dreamlike quality that invites kids to wonder about the journey, the train, and the nature of belief. The story doesn't over-explain; it leaves space for readers to fill in details and imagine themselves aboard. It's not interactive or hands-on creative, but it sparks the kind of quiet, contemplative imagination that lingers.

Safe

98

This is about as safe as children's literature gets. No violence, no scary content, no inappropriate themes. The most 'intense' moment is the anticipation and mystery of the journey itself, which is handled with a soft, magical touch. Common Sense Media parent reviews confirm it's beloved across all ages with no safety concerns. The 40th anniversary edition maintains the original's gentle tone.

Enriching

85

The book explores themes of belief, wonder, and the transition from childhood innocence to skepticism—heady stuff wrapped in a Christmas story. It invites conversations about what we choose to believe and why that matters. The rich, detailed illustrations reward close study. That said, it's primarily a mood piece rather than a story with clear lessons or skill-building. It enriches emotionally and philosophically more than educationally, which is valuable but somewhat narrow in scope.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

The artwork is genuinely stunning—moody, detailed, and unlike anything else in the picture book world
Captures the specific magic of Christmas Eve anticipation without being saccharine or commercial
Invites real conversations about belief, imagination, and what we choose to hold onto as we grow up
A legitimate classic that's stood the test of time (40 years!) and still feels fresh
The quiet, contemplative tone is a nice antidote to overstimulating holiday media

⚠

What to Watch For

This is a slow, atmospheric story—kids who need constant action may zone out
The theme centers on believing in Santa, which may or may not align with your family's approach to Christmas
It's more of a mood piece than a plot-driven adventure; some kids will be mesmerized, others will be bored
The movie adaptation exists and is... divisive (uncanny valley animation), so manage expectations if they've seen that first

Conversation Starters

"If a mysterious train showed up at your house at midnight, would you get on? What would you bring?"
"The boy can't hear the bell at the end, but his sister can't either now. Why do you think that happens?"
"What's something you believe in that other people might not? Why is it important to you?"
"The North Pole in this book looks so different from other Christmas stories—what do you notice about how it's drawn?"
"Do you think the journey really happened, or was it a dream? Does it matter?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic