Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Most early counting primers are dry chores designed to tick off a developmental milestone. Mo Willems takes the opposite route by letting his famously melodramatic Pigeon flat-out refuse to participate. The bird argues that counting is for the birds, claims he already counted yesterday, and insists he has far more important business to handle.
The tactile touch-and-trace channels give little hands something concrete to do while you supply the shouting bird voice. It delivers solid numeral practice wrapped in enough genuine comedy that reading it six times before breakfast will not ruin your morning.
Age Fit
Ages 1 to 4. Babies will like tracing the grooved numbers, while older toddlers get the joke that the Pigeon is acting ridiculous.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
92
Mirrors toddler stubbornness with Mo Willems's trademark theatrical tantrums, letting kids laugh at defiance without modeling anything genuinely problematic.
Imaginative
88
Flips the predictable counting primer into a comedy routine where the protagonist actively protests the premise of the book.
Safe
100
Sturdy board book construction with touch-and-trace textures. Zero objectionable content, jump scares, or emotional landmines.
Enriching
86
Pairs early numeral recognition and tactile finger-tracing with comedic read-aloud language that makes repetition painless for everyone in the room.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Subverts standard counting boredom by giving the kid the upper hand over a bird who insists he already counted plenty yesterday.
Touch-and-trace numbers give fidgety toddler fingers a physical groove to follow across thick board pages.
Built for big read-aloud energy, giving adults an excuse to do overdramatic voices that actually hold a two-year-old's focus.
⚠
What to Watch For
The Pigeon's theatrical excuses might get adopted at bedtime or dinner when you ask for two more bites.
Conversation Starters
"Why do you think the Pigeon is so mad about counting?"
"Can we count to ten before the Pigeon gets his feathers ruffled?"
"What is the silliest excuse you can make up to get out of cleaning your room?"
Deep Dive
How to read it without losing your voice
The Pigeon books only work if you commit to the bit. If you read this flatly, it is just another counting book with a blue bird on the cover. Mo Willems writes these like stage scripts for parents. The entire gag hinges on your willingness to deliver full-throated, melodramatic toddler logic while your kid plays the sensible straight man.
Here is how to make the tactile parts work:
Let your kid guide your finger through the trace grooves while you complain in character about how exhausting numbers are.
When the Pigeon storms off, pause and let the child do the actual counting out loud to prove they can do what the bird refuses to do.
Keep it in rotation for early number tracing, but treat it primarily as comedy practice.
Board books that try to teach math usually feel like flashcards with a binding. This one succeeds because it assumes toddlers already know what a ridiculous stall tactic looks like.