Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

The Paper is trying to catch lightning in a bottle by having the same documentary crew from The Office find a new subject. It's a clever meta-premise, but let's be real: we're drowning in mockumentaries at this point.

The journalism angle is actually the most interesting part here - in 2025, a show about reviving a local newspaper feels both nostalgic and urgent. There's genuine educational value in exploring how communities get their news and why local journalism matters. That said, this is still primarily a comedy, not a civics lesson.

The problem? We have almost no data. No content rating, no critical consensus, just a single TMDB score of 7.1 (which is... fine?). Without knowing the actual humor style, character quality, or whether it's trying too hard to be The Office 2.0, it's tough to give a strong recommendation.

If your teens loved The Office or Abbott Elementary, this might hit the spot. But if mockumentaries feel played out to you, this probably won't change your mind. Worth a pilot episode watch, but don't expect it to revolutionize the genre.

Age Fit

Best for teens and adults (14+) who enjoy workplace comedies and can appreciate the journalism angle. Younger kids will likely find the mockumentary pacing slow and the newspaper setting unrelatable.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

72

Mockumentary format following newspaper revival suggests workplace comedy with positive themes around journalism and community. The Office-style format typically models cooperation and character growth, though workplace comedies can include mild conflict and awkward humor. Without specific content details, assuming similar tone to its spiritual predecessor.

Imaginative

58

Mockumentary format is well-worn territory at this point (2025), and following a newspaper revival is timely but not particularly fresh as a concept. The premise suggests observational humor rather than creative world-building. Documentary-style shows tend toward realism over imagination, though character-driven comedy can surprise.

Safe

78

Workplace comedies in the mockumentary style are typically safe for families, with humor derived from character quirks rather than graphic content. No content ratings available, but the premise suggests PG-13 level content at most. TMDB 7.1 rating suggests broad appeal. Kids mode available on platform is a positive signal.

Enriching

65

Journalism and local newspaper themes offer potential discussions about media literacy, community reporting, and the changing news landscape. Workplace dynamics can model professional relationships. However, comedy is the primary goal rather than education. Entertainment value depends on execution, which is unknown with no critical reviews available.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Mockumentary format that worked for The Office could deliver character-driven humor and heart
Journalism theme is timely and could spark conversations about local news, media literacy, and community reporting
Workplace comedy typically models collaboration and problem-solving in professional settings
TMDB rating of 7.1 suggests viewers are finding it reasonably enjoyable

⚠

What to Watch For

No content rating available yet, so preview first if watching with younger kids - workplace comedies can include mild adult themes and awkward humor
Mockumentary format is pretty saturated by 2025, so this may feel derivative if you've watched Parks and Rec, The Office, Abbott Elementary, etc.
Very new show with minimal reviews, so quality is still TBD

Conversation Starters

"Where does your family get news? Do you know if there's a local newspaper in our town?"
"Why do you think newspapers are struggling when we have the internet?"
"What makes something 'newsworthy'? What stories matter to a community?"
"Have you ever thought about being a journalist or reporter?"

Stills

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about The Paper? Put this WISE score on your site