Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Look, this movie is a mess. With a 13% critic score on Rotten Tomatoes and a dismal 33 on Metacritic, City of Bones represents everything that went wrong with the post-Twilight YA adaptation rush. It tries to cram an entire fantasy world into two hours, resulting in confusing exposition dumps and underdeveloped characters.

The biggest problem? That incest subplot. Even though it's eventually revealed as a manipulation, having your teen protagonists believe they're siblings while experiencing romantic feelings is genuinely disturbing content that's handled clumsily. Combined with the overwrought melodrama and dated 2013 Hot Topic aesthetic, this is a hard watch in 2025.

If your teen is a die-hard fan of Cassandra Clare's novels, they might get some enjoyment from seeing the characters visualized. But honestly? Just hand them the books instead. The source material is significantly better, and you'll avoid two hours of cringe-inducing dialogue and confusing CGI battles.

The planned sequel was cancelled for good reason—even the target audience couldn't get behind this one. It's not unwatchable, but it's close.

Age Fit

Best for 14-16 year olds who are already fans of the book series and can look past the film's flaws. The incest subplot and intense romantic melodrama make it inappropriate for younger teens, while the poor execution and dated aesthetic make it a tough sell for anyone who hasn't read the books.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

52

A teen protagonist discovers her heritage and teams up with allies, modeling some cooperation and bravery. However, the film leans heavily into brooding romance tropes and melodrama typical of early-2010s YA adaptations. The tone can be emotionally intense with family trauma (missing mother, mysterious past) and romantic tension that overshadows character development. Pacing is uneven, trying to cram too much worldbuilding into a single film.

Imaginative

58

The Shadowhunter mythology—half-angel warriors, Downworld filled with demons, vampires, and magical creatures—offers a rich fantasy premise borrowed from Cassandra Clare's novels. The alternate realm concept and ancient artifact quest have imaginative potential. However, the film's execution is derivative, heavily borrowing from Twilight, Harry Potter, and Buffy aesthetics without adding much originality. The worldbuilding feels rushed and generic rather than inviting deeper exploration.

Safe

61

Common Sense Media rates this at 13+, which aligns with PG-13 territory. There's fantasy violence (demon fighting, battles), some scary creature designs, and intense sequences that could startle younger viewers. Romantic elements include some kissing and tension but nothing explicit. The incest subplot twist (later revealed as false) is genuinely disturbing and inappropriate for the target age range, even if resolved. No graphic gore or nudity, but the emotional intensity around family secrets and the uncomfortable romantic complications lower the safety score for younger teens.

Enriching

38

The film attempts themes of identity, belonging, and finding your place in a hidden world, but executes them superficially. Character growth is minimal, with most development sacrificed for convoluted plot mechanics and forced romance. The 13% critic score and 33 Metacritic reflect poor storytelling that doesn't offer meaningful takeaways. While there are moments about loyalty and standing up to evil, they're buried under clunky dialogue and melodrama. Entertainment value is also compromised—the 5.8 IMDb and 2.6/5 Letterboxd ratings suggest even fans of the genre found it lackluster.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

If your teen loved the Cassandra Clare books, they might enjoy seeing the Shadowhunter world visualized (even if imperfectly)
The fantasy premise of a hidden world of demon hunters, vampires, and magical creatures offers escapist appeal for younger teens discovering urban fantasy
Can spark interest in the source material novels, which are genuinely better and more developed than this adaptation
Lily Collins brings some charm to Clary, and the diverse supernatural cast includes interesting character types even if underwritten

⚠

What to Watch For

That deeply uncomfortable incest subplot—Clary and Jace believe they're siblings for much of the film while having romantic feelings (it's later revealed as false, but yikes)
Fantasy violence with demons, battles, and some scary creature designs that could be intense for younger or sensitive viewers
Melodramatic romance that dominates the plot and may feel cringe to modern teens who've moved past the Twilight era
Confusing worldbuilding that rushes through explanations—even book fans found it hard to follow

Conversation Starters

"What would you do if you suddenly discovered you had secret powers and a completely different heritage?"
"The movie has this whole 'forbidden love' thing that turns out to be based on a lie—how did that storyline make you feel?"
"If you could be part of a secret world fighting supernatural creatures, would you want that responsibility or prefer normal life?"
"How does this compare to other fantasy worlds you've seen like Harry Potter or Percy Jackson?"

Stills