Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
If your kid is looking for the next big magic series, this is it. It’s the magic school book for the 2020s—diverse, imaginative, and deeply relevant.
Dhonielle Clayton has managed to take the 'special kid goes to magic school' trope and make it feel completely fresh by ditching the stuffy British boarding school vibes for a global, sky-high academy. It’s a solid pick for any kid who loves a good mystery and wants to see a world that looks a bit more like our own, just with more levity and flying ships.
Age Fit
Perfect for the 9-12 crowd. It’s sophisticated enough for middle schoolers but accessible enough for a strong 3rd-grade reader who wants a meaty fantasy world.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
The story centers on Ella Durand, the first Conjuror at a prestigious magic school. It leans heavily into loyalty, family roots, and finding your people when the establishment doesn't want you there. It handles the 'mean girl' and 'skeptical teacher' tropes with more emotional depth than your average middle-grade novel.
Imaginative
94
Dhonielle Clayton built a magic school in the sky (The Arcanum Training Institute) that actually feels global. Instead of just one cultural perspective, you get magic based on the five senses and traditions from all over the world. It’s vibrant, colorful, and moves past the tired European-centric fantasy cliches.
Safe
95
It's a standard middle-grade fantasy. There is some peril, a few scary magical creatures, and the tension of a missing teacher, but nothing that would traumatize a 9-year-old. No explicit language or inappropriate content—just the usual 'magic school mystery' stakes.
Enriching
92
The book is a masterclass in using fantasy to talk about real-world systemic prejudice without being preachy. It forces readers to look at how 'different' types of magic (or people) are labeled as 'bad' just because they don't fit the status quo. It’s great for building empathy and critical thinking about social structures.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
The world-building is top-tier; the Arcanum Institute feels like a place you actually want to visit.
It tackles heavy themes like prejudice and 'othering' through a magical lens that kids can actually grasp.
Ella is a fantastic protagonist—brave, vulnerable, and deeply connected to her family's unique culture.
It’s a fast-paced mystery that keeps kids who are 'bored of reading' actually turning the pages.
⚠
What to Watch For
The 'Conjuror vs. Marveller' conflict is a direct parallel to racism and systemic bias, which might spark some big questions.
There’s some mild fantasy violence and 'magic school' bullying that can get a bit intense for very sensitive younger readers.
Conversation Starters
"Why do you think the Marvellers were so afraid of Ella’s Conjuror magic before they even met her?"
"If you could have magic based on one of your five senses, which one would you pick and why?"
"Ella has to deal with a lot of people judging her. How does she stay true to herself without getting bitter?"
"Which part of the Arcanum Institute would you want to visit first?"
